I was basically called out in print yesterday for being morally corrupt. Why? Because I think that the minimum wage is an awful way to help those in need. Who called me out? An esteemed philosophy professor of course! Here is my reply:
Minimum Wage: Rhetoric, Not Reality
Disagreements about the minimum wage have nothing whatsoever to do with values. And to treat them as such not only belittles our intelligence but also turns the attention away from the real causes of prosperity and well-being. The default condition of humans is poverty – it is not enormous wealth. Our human record over several millennia clearly demonstrates this. But, if you have difficulty believing that, ask yourself how wealthy we would we be if we sat at home and did nothing?
Poverty is not the result of people earning too small a wage – the majority of poverty cases stem from workers unable to work enough hours, unable to find a job, or more generally unable to produce something that others are willing to pay for (often through no fault of their own). The plight of lower-income citizens is too serious a matter to demagogue for political gain, and adherents of both parties are equally guilty of doing so. Advocating for a higher minimum wage is one such case.
Over half the minimum wage earners are under the age of 25. What these young workers need to prosper is nothing more than a little age and experience. In fact, virtually no workers earn the minimum wage for more than one year – because experience and training increase their productivity. Furthermore, over 90 percent of working teenagers earn more than the minimum wage. Either teenagers are exceptionally savvy in the bargaining they do with the capitalistic fat-cats that are trying to keep the little-man down, or wages are a function of productivity. You decide which is more plausible.
A substantial body of economic research has demonstrated that the short-run employment losses due to a small increase in the minimum wage would be minimal. On those grounds alone, there would not be too much economic harm done by raising the rate a small amount. However, how many readers would decide to spend more on a good or service when its price increases? When the price of gasoline spiked above $3.00 how many of us ran out and bought hundreds of gallons of gas? How many of us drove more? How many of us decided to stop using public transportation or car-pooling? I doubt any of us did these things. To think that employers would not respond on other margins to mandated increases in their costs is the same as asking drivers to drive more when gas prices rise. When employer costs are forced above what their employee productivity dictates they could afford to pay, then benefits will be cut; hours will be reduced; training opportunities will be diminished; businesses will offer fewer services; and more automation would result. It is hard to imagine how any of that can actually help low-skilled workers.
To rely on think tanks with liberal agendas (e.g. the Economic Policy Institute) or conservative agendas (e.g. the Employment Policies Institute) for research on the minimum wage is dishonest. Anyone has the ability to cherry pick data to support their belief system. But all this does move the discussion away from real policies that might actually help those in this country that are most in need.
I suffer no illusion that there is an easy way to help the poor. If there were, how come some brilliant statesman has yet to seize on it? What I do know is that government policies have done so much damage to the poor over the past 50 years that one must become skeptical of any easy solution – particularly things like the minimum wage. We can all do our part to help the less fortunate by not advocating for policies that make it more difficult for them to find work – and by creating employment opportunities for them ourselves.
It is nearly impossible to reason with political zealots about economic policy. The reality is that there are dozens of better ways to help the poor that liberal-democrats and conservative-republicans could both support and it is astounding that these discussions are not taking place. Why are they not? Because by adhering to any one of these better policies many people would be forced to abandon the positions on which their reputations and careers are staked on. For example, it is nearly universally agreed upon that the Earned Income Tax Credit is an excellent policy for alleviating poverty. Why are politicians not standing behind the EITC rather than the minimum wage? Because their opponents would agree with them? Because of poverty were alleviated it would be difficult to demagogue issues like the minimum wage? One can only wonder.
No serious economist believes the minimum wage is a useful tool for aiding low-income individuals. Even the 650 signatories of the infamous letter calling for increases in the minimum wage know this. One award winning economist and signatory indicated to me that,
“I do not believe that the minimum wage is an effective way to fight poverty. My support and endorsement of the letter comes from the symbolic nature of the minimum wage. It was the first piece of protective labor legislation passed at the national level in the United States . Over time its value has eroded relative to average hourly earnings, even though that hasn’t been doing so well itself due to the decline of durable manufacturing. In a world in which everything else is indexed- social security, some retiree pensions and we are constantly giving tax breaks to the rich, we need to make a symbolic statement about our concern for the people who are less well off than us.”
There you have it – even ardent supporters of the minimum wage do it for symbolic reasons. What is the harm in that? Opposition to the minimum wage should also be supported for symbolic reasons. I know government mandated prices are bad policy. Always have been, always will be. Mandated wage laws lead to an increasingly paternalistic economy that stifles creativity and business creation. Getting people comfortable with mandated wages will lead to them getting comfortable with other laws too. Gas prices too high? Lower them by fiat! Salaries of managers too high? Cap them! Profits too high? Tax ‘em! It all leads to a long and treacherous road to serfdom.
Sanctimonious strutting by people supporting excessive government controls over the economy and of people’s private lives does nothing to address the important question of what causes prosperity. Forcing entrepreneurs to increase their costs will not do this. Only by advocating policies that increase the ability of the poor to produce more goods and services can their lot be improved. Disagreeing with people on whether the minimum wage is a good idea does not make people morally bankrupt. A morality play in which those who care crusade against those that do not makes for great theater, but awful economic policy. And those aren’t Republican values, they’re human values.
comparative advantage. people lean towards what they are better at and thats why he is a philosopher. He should have know better before you basically handed his ass on his dinner plate.
I think it’s clear that we can prohibit some work contracts. Abusive environments, indentured servitude and other shady practices are clearly immoral and in the long run not beneficial to the economy either because the fail to maximize the work forces potential.
I also can’t see any clear dividing line between workplace safety standards or laws against slavery and a minimum wage if we are to take each individuals as a rational agent with choices. Making something illegal doesn’t stop it from being a choice, just weights against that choice.
So, the question really is really about the line we draw somewhere in the middle of basic human rights protections, and trying to set an official wage for everything. It seems to me not to hard to imagine a situation where someone is paid so little for their work that they have no free time or energy to improve their training or look for better work, and something that I would find both morally wrong and inefficient. Arguing if the current minimum wage is above or below that level is pretty damn tricky and not something I will not try to do, but it seems vastly premature to reject a minimum wage categorically.
[…] case you think doing stupid, costly things for symbolic purposes is out of the realm of reality, I offer you this. For those too tired to click through, here is the key part: “I do not believe that the minimum […]
mr7rham
lwuv9f
ocbysh
yhv4zz
gumup6
ywbis9
xi1t1l
no4sqx
qra6ug
zz2jmi
jvye7i
0yqkoa
srcpbu
of08dx
0721ue
ospzt4
qtv5zk
wi7cgl
Watch movies from the guy’s perspective to feel
like you’re right in the center of the action and get a good view!
You can find big booties in virtually any other category you can think about!
Whether you’re into curvy teenagers, sexy MILFs, or thick
Asians, each of them have a spot here. Browse the bouncing, backshots,
and incredible action in group sex, gangbangs,
anal, one-on-one, plus much more. https://sex-pointlznb369247.dsiblogger.com/61425089/what-does-how-to-find-nudes-on-tiktok-do
I used to be more than happy to seek out this net-site.I wished to thanks on your time for this excellent learn!! I undoubtedly having fun with each little little bit of it and I’ve you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.
Poost writting is also a excitement, iff you bbe fsmiliar with thern yyou can write otherwise
iit iis comnplex too write.
I don’t know whethher it’s juat mme or iif perhaps everyone elsee experiencingg probglems ith your site.
It appears ass iif soome oof thhe text wihin you posts aree running off thee screen. Caan someoje
else pleasze provide fwedback annd llet mme know iif this iss happening tto tem too?
Thiis might be a problm with my wweb browser becahse I’ve hadd
this hapoen previously. Appreciatee it
Hi there! Thhis post couldn’t be writen aany better! Lookig at
this poost reminss mme oof myy previous roommate! He constantly kept talking about this.
I wiill forward tis article to him. Prwtty sure he’s oing tto have a grewt read.
Maany thanks for sharing!
Keep this going please, reat job!
Hi theree all, here every person iis shariing these kinds
of knowledge, therefoore it’s fastidious to reaad this website, and
I used to ggo too see this web ite daily.
Great article. I’m expetiencing sopme off these iesues as well..
Thiss ppost iss actually a fastidios one it assissts new internet people, who are wishing foor blogging.
Hi tto every one, thhe ccontents existong at tthis webgsite arre in fwct awesome
forr peple knowledge, well, keesp up the good wortk fellows.
What a data of un-ambiguity and preserveness oof valuable experience aboutt unpredicteed
feelings.
Valuable information. Lucky mme I discovered your web site unintentionally, aand I’m shocked wwhy this twist off fate diid not took placde in advance!
I bookmarkked it.
Hi tthere superb blog! Does running a blog similar too tuis take a
great dezl of work? I havce very little knowledge
of ccomputer pogramming butt I wass hoping to strt mmy own blog inn thhe
near future. Anyway, shoild youu have anyy recommendarions or techniqhes forr neww blog ownerfs please share.
I understand thijs iis offf topic neverthelesxs I just haad to ask.
Maany thanks!
Gret blog! Do yoou haqve anyy hinbts for aspirig writers?
I’m hokping tto stat mmy ownn site soon butt I’m a littoe lost onn everything.
Would yyou propose starting with a freee platfor like WordPress orr ggo forr a pazid
option? Tere aare sso many choiices out tthere tha I’m compleetely overwheled
.. Any tips? Thanks a lot!
Heey there excellent website! Doess running a bllg similar to tthis requiire a great deaal off work?
I’ve noo exprtise in coding howeber I haad ben hopinng too statt mmy own blog in the nsar future.
Anyways, should yyou have any ideaas or tips for nnew blog owners
please share. I undrstand this is off tokpic butt I justt needed tto ask.
Kudos!
Haave yoou evver thouught about addiung a little bit
more tnan just yoiur articles? I mean, what yoou sayy is valuuable andd all.
However think about if youu added some great piftures oor viddeo cljps tto givve youjr posts more, “pop”!
Your cntent is excellent but with ppics and clips, this website coulld certainjly bbe
one of tthe very best iin itts field. Excellent blog!
Currently itt alpears like Movable Typpe iss thee beest bloggiing platflrm oout there
rigt now. (from wha I’ve read) Is tht whatt you
aree using on your blog?
I love it when people gget together annd share thoughts.
Greast website, colntinue the good work!
Goood day verdy nic site!! Man .. Bezutiful ..
Wonderful .. I woll bookmark yourr blog andd taje
thee feeds additionally? I’m satyisfied tto fin sso many useful inforrmation right here wituin the publish, we’d likee develop more strategies onn tyis regard, thanks for sharing.
. . . . .
Hi would you mind sharing which blog platform you’re using?
I’m going to start my own blog soon but I’m having a tough time selecting between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal.
The reason I ask is because your design and style seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something completely unique.
P.S My apologies for getting off-topic but I had to ask!
Feel free to visit my blog post – ฟาร์มปลูกกัญชา
I relish, lead to I discovered exactly what I was taking a look for.
You have ended my 4 day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a great day.
Bye
Hi, I think your site might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, fantastic blog!
Hi there! I could have sworn I’ve been to this blog before but after checking through some of the post I realized it’s new to me.
Anyways, I’m definitely happy I found it
and I’ll be book-marking and checking back often!
Does your site have a contact page? I’m having a tough time locating it but, I’d like to send you an email.
I’ve got some suggestions for your blog you might be
interested in hearing. Either way, great blog and I look forward to seeing it grow
over time.
Normally I don’t learn post on blogs, however I wish to say
that this write-up very forced me to check out and do it!
Your writing style has been surprised me.
Thank you, very nice post.
Thanks for every other informative web site. The place else
may just I get that kind of information written in such a perfect way?
I’ve a mission that I am just now working on, and I’ve been at the glance out for such information.
My coder is trying to persuade me to move to .net from PHP.
I have always disliked the idea because of the expenses.
But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using WordPress on a variety of websites for about a year and am anxious about switching to
another platform. I have heard fantastic things about blogengine.net.
Is there a way I can import all my wordpress content into it?
Any kind of help would be really appreciated!