How many times have you heard directly or at least been able to infer that, “Economics just doesn’t apply to that!” I hear it quite often, even from within the echo-chamber of economists. You’ll probably most likely encounter it in discussions/arguments about health care and the environment, or some other social phenomenon of importance. Before getting to my point, I find it particularly ironic when people say “economics doesn’t apply to health care” or “economics does not work in health care.” Why? It was a famous economist who wrote a paper a half-century ago laying out the economic problem of health care. His name was Kenneth Arrow. When Arrow wrote that paper, he did not end it with, “ahh, so I’ve demonstrated that economics does not APPLY to health care, and since I’ve done this I recommend that there is nothing an economist can do or say on the issue.” Far from it.
The adoption of that Arrowian position on the “economic broken-ness” of health care to mean that economics does not apply to it very much reminds me of the way that folks have adopted the language of “externalities” to claim that economics cannot deal with environmental issues. I’ve spilled too much virtual ink on that topic to want to continue it now.
But let’s take the comment seriously as both economists and interested readers. What can it possibly mean? When someone says, “economics does not apply to health care” they have to know something about what economics is (indeed many economics majors still cannot articulate this after 4 years of classes). Then they probably have to articulate what they mean by “health care.” Do they mean the ability to produce and sell an aspirin? My ability to purchase an ice-pack or an ace bandage? The challenge of caring for the elderly? Health insurance? Everything health related? It’s no more useful to have a discussion about “health care” than it is for me and you to arrange to meet today at 4:30 to talk about “things.”
But assume we know what folks mean when they say health care. What can it possibly mean to say that economics does not apply? Well, we know the most basic lesson of economics, as it is a study of human behavior, is that people respond to incentives. So to argue that economics does not apply to health care is to say:
In health care, people do NOT respond to incentives.
I find that to not only be an implausible proposition, but also one that is not believed by those who make the claim that economics does not apply to health care.
OK, so if we don’t mean that incentives don’t matter in health care, let’s move onto the fundamental reason we need to study economics: scarcity. Put simply, there’s not enough stuff to go around. And because of this problem, any time we aim to secure more of something we value, the laws of nature dictate that we must trade something off to obtain it. So, do folks believe that economics does not apply to health care believe that:
In health care, there is no such thing as scarcity.
Well, if that’s the case, then as my friend Alex says, “the jig is up.” Repeal Obamacare immediately, as it is unnecessary. Repeal Medicare immediately, as it is unnecessary. Eliminate all insurance companies, as they, too, are unnecessary. It would be great if heart-bypass operations performed themselves, using no electricity or materials that are valued in other uses. It would be great if I could call a doctor (in a time-warp of course, because there would be no opportunity cost of my call) and actually get a response from a person who gave a damn. It would be amazing if I could fall off a rockface while climbing and blink my eyes three times to find my fractured tibia healed. Of course this is all ludicrous. The problem people see with health care in fact is that they think it is more scarce than many other “goods.” And it is when goods are most scarce that the insights of economics would be particularly useful to appreciate. I’ve always argued that there’d be no economists in heaven (maybe that’s what makes heaven heaven).
OK, so people really don’t mean that. Maybe people mean that the way people respond in the face of scarcity is “different” when it comes to health care and the environment. Economists are regularly ridiculed for observing that when there is not enough stuff to go around, people tend to follow a typical hueristic to help them decide what trade-offs are worth making and which ones are not. The term we have for that is “economizing behavior” but you have heard it ridiculed as “rationality” or “efficiency.” When it comes to the fact that there is not enough health care for me to have all that I want, or not enough health care for the collective of Americans to get all that they want, do people really mean that people do NOT try to select the actions where the expected additional benefits exceed the expected additional costs? This is, folks, what we mean by efficiency – that when we choose ex ante (not analyzing it ex post) we make the best choice we can for ourselves.
It’s not funny how “the obsession with efficiency among economists” has become the object of scorn. Efficiency boils down to individuals TRYING to make choices that “they like” and that are “good for us.” This, then is a particularly interesting irony. Folks argue that economics doesn’t apply to health care, but in the next breath ridicule people (economists) for studying the economizing behavior of agents within the health-care sector. What’s it going to be? Pretty soon we’ll be reading people arguing that “math doesn’t apply to football” by showing that coaches underestimate the probability of success by going for it on fourth-down.
Economics is nothing more than the study of human action under conditions of scarcity. People may not like being told that bread does not bake itself and drop into our mouths warm and crusty upon our commands. People may not like being told that the scarcity problem tends to be handled better when private property institutions are established and respected and the Rule of Law is part of the cultural fabric. People may not like being told that scarcity applies just as well to the choices we face over-time. People may not like being understanding that their beloved political gods are tugged by the same pull of incentives that ordinary Joes are. But not liking it doesn’t mean a darn thing about whether economics applies.
What do I think about all of this? People like to mentally substitute things they like or can feel for things that they don’t want to have to think hard about. So when folks say, “economics doesn’t apply to the environment!” I strongly suspect that what they mean instead is that “capitalism” or “freely exchanging” should not be practiced for environmental amenities. That is an entirely different position to take. It’s one I will argue in the future that opponents still do not understand. Indeed, the more serious the problems we face, the more attention we ought to pay to economics and the more respect ought to be given for the possibility of voluntary association to operate.
i can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard that and wanted to pull all my hair out
Mark that one for a chapter in one of your next books. WC has a talent for expressing things in refreshing, intriguing, original ways, even to the most jaded among us. I volunteer to be an editor, assuming I can afford the time, of course.
Excellent points. Thank you for the reminder that the basics still apply.
Strong post Mike.
lsunumuq
2cqdee
xph38d
qf5xqc
lRCUAFHJZhcBvznu
hSVgNGqQWfHiR
Very interesting information!Perfect just what I was looking for! “Water is the most neglected nutrient in your diet but one of the most vital.” by Kelly Barton.
Nice answers in returdn of this mztter with genyine arguments annd
describiong the whole thing on the topic of that.
Howdy! I know this is kinda off topic nevertheless I’d figured I’d ask. Would you be interested in exchanging links or maybe guest writing a blog article or vice-versa? My website discusses a lot of the same subjects as yours and I think we could greatly benefit from each other. If you are interested feel free to send me an e-mail. I look forward to hearing from you! Wonderful blog by the way!
Модные советы по созданию стильных образов на каждый день.
Заметки экспертов, события, все новинки и шоу.
https://emurmansk.ru/pub/2024-09-10-demna-gvasaliya-revolyutsioner-mody-i-kreativnyy-provokator/
I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was good. I don’t know who you are but definitely you are going to a famous blogger if you aren’t already 😉 Cheers!
Valuable information. Lucky me I found your web site by accident, and I’m shocked why this accident didn’t happened earlier! I bookmarked it.
I’m often to blogging and i actually admire your content. The article has actually peaks my interest. I am going to bookmark your website and maintain checking for new information.
1hpq0k
Стильные советы по подбору модных образов на каждый день.
Статьи экспертов, новости, все показы и мероприятия.
https://watches.superpodium.com/fashion/2804-7-reasons-to-love-patek-philippe-nautilus/
Thanks, I have recently been hunting for details about this subject for ages and yours is the best I have found so far.
I think other site proprietors should take this web site as an model, very clean and great user friendly style and design, as well as the content. You are an expert in this topic!
Стильные советы по выбору крутых луков на любой день.
Статьи экспертов, новости, все коллекции и шоу.
https://sofiamoda.ru/style/2024-10-03-principe-di-bologna-roskosh-italyanskogo-stilya-i-elegantnost-na-kazhdyy-den/
I am always thought about this, thanks for putting up.
hi!,I relly like yourr wrriting vsry much! shae we bee in contact moe aboout yojr artiicle onn AOL?
I requite a specialist in thhis houuse too unraverl my problem.
Maay be that is you! Looking forward to ook you.
What’s Happening i’m new to this, I stumbld pon thiis I have discovered It positiely usful
andd iit hhas aided me outt loads. I hopee too
gve a conmtribution & asszist different users like
its aaided me. Goood job.
5b1hba
There is clearly a bunch to realize about this. I believe you made some good points in features also.
Официальный интернет-магазин Боттега Венета предлагает широкий ассортимент оригинальной продукции от знаменитого производителя. В нашем каталоге вы сможете подобрать и приобрести изделия актуальных коллекций с возможностью доставки по Москве и всей России.
https://bottega-official.ru
Cheapest private proxies – price ranges under $0.15 for every proxies! Acquire at this moment and have 50 price cut for ones proxies offer – https://DreamProxies.com
793477 881882Hi there! Do you use Twitter? Id like to follow you if that would be ok. Im undoubtedly enjoying your weblog and appear forward to new posts. 587124
I don’t even know the waay I ended up here, howevewr I believed tis submiut wass great.
I ddo nott understand who you’re but certainly you’re going to a famous blogger iin tthe event yoou
aren’t already. Cheers!
180259 747904Just wanna input on couple of common issues, The web site layout is perfect, the articles is truly excellent : D. 448399
Hello very cool web site!! Guy .. Excellent .. Wonderful .. I’ll bookmark your site and take the feeds additionallyKI am satisfied to seek out so many useful info right here within the publish, we want work out more strategies on this regard, thank you for sharing. . . . . .
Thank you for another informative website. Where else could I get that type of info written in such an ideal way? I have a project that I’m just now working on, and I have been on the look out for such info.
This actually answered my problem, thanks!
Hello there! Quick question that’s entirely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My website looks weird when viewing from my apple iphone. I’m trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able to correct this problem. If you have any suggestions, please share. With thanks!
I discovered your weblog site on google and test a few of your early posts. Proceed to keep up the excellent operate. I simply additional up your RSS feed to my MSN Information Reader. Looking for forward to studying more from you later on!…
Very fantastic information can be found on web blog.
What’s Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It absolutely useful and it has helped me out loads. I hope to contribute & aid other users like its aided me. Good job.
you are my intake, I possess few web logs and often run out from to brand : (.
Its like yoou rea mmy mind! Youu seerm too know so much about
this, like yyou wrote thee book inn it oor something.
I think that you can do with sme pics too drive the
meswage hoome a bit, but otyer thuan that, this is excellent
blog. A fanastic read. I’ll certainly be back.