Alert: This is unscientific, but then again, neither is the stuff being done to the economy.
On September 20th, 2008, we were warned by the Treasury Secretary that failure to enact bailout legislation would lead to dire consequences – particularly if the legislation was not approved quickly and as proposed. After a flirt with reason, Congress did the expected on October 3 and passed the bill.
Look at what has happened since to three indicators:
Home Prices: fell by 2% in October, fell by another 2% in November, and fell by another 2% in December. That is a 6% decline nationwide in just 3 months. Remember that home prices throughout history have never fallen that much in a single year. If you look at the Fed’s Flow of Funds data, you can see that when the bill passed, the value of real estate in the US was approximately $21.4 trillion. So, a decline of 6% in just three months is a loss of $1.28 trillion of real estate value.
Stock Equity: see the following chart. On October 3, the S&P 500 closed at 1,099.23. Today it stands at 712.87. That’s only a 35% decline in a three month period. Take a guess at how large the single worst year of equity performance has been, and how that 35% compares to it. Again from the flow of funds, the total value of household investments in the stock market and mutual fund shares (not all equity but I am undercounting nonetheless) was $11.45 trillion. So, a decline of 35% in just three months is a loss of $4 trillion in equity value.
Bank Failures: In the 14 months from the start of the credit crisis until the bailout passed, we see that 14 banks were placed in FDIC receivership (i.e. they failed). In the 5 months since the rescue package, 29 banks have been placed in FDIC receivership. And most of the toxic stuff that seems to be causing problems still sits on the balance sheets of the most troubled banks.
Now, I am not sure these real estate and equity losses are to be bemoaned – those values could have been inflated to begin with. The point is however that the bailout was sold to us as a way of preventing disaster.
Phew! Just imagine what would have happened if we had not taken swift and decisive action. I also wonder what would be the government’s definition of “disaster”? They seem to use such a term at their own convenience depending on what they need us to believe. To justify past programs, they will say that the above is not a disaster. To justify future spending, they get to say that it is (listen to the state of the union again).
984645 814942I believe this web internet site contains really superb composed articles posts . 50173
358066 732269I dont think Ive read anything like this before. So good to locate somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. thank for starting this up. This internet site is something that is necessary on the web, someone with a bit originality. Good job for bringing something new towards the internet! 408075
273254 524359Dead written articles , Really enjoyed reading . 391542
793776 417311Pretty section of content material. I just stumbled upon your weblog and in accession capital to assert that I get actually enjoyed account your weblog posts. Any way I will probably be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you access consistently speedily. 501421
84514 948450An attention-grabbing discussion is worth comment. I believe which you really should write much more on this matter, it wont be a taboo topic nonetheless normally persons are not sufficient to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers 317055
686782 722064Intending start up a enterprise around the web involves revealing marketing plus items not only to females locally, however somehow to several buyers who are web-based as a rule. e-learning 999561
887037 803917Nothing better than Bing discovering us a good internet site related to what I was seeking for. 962559
756892 521553hi and thanks regarding the specific post ive actually been looking regarding this kind of information online for sum time these days hence thanks a lot 724261