The economic way of thinking demonstrates that it is marginal ðecisions that matter. Thus, students that learn about the economic way of thinking understand that it might not be a good idea to institute the death penalty for crimes like littering and petty theft, even if society really hates having litter and petty theft. Why is this?
Thinking at the margin allows us to look out for unintended consequences! The term margin is perhaps a bit confusing – but all we really mean by “marginal” thinking is to focus on what benefits and costs change when you make a decision – it is only those that matter.
While being tougher on those specific crimes may very well reduce the amount of litter and petty theft (it raises the cost of committing theft and littering), think about how this harsh penalty affects decisions at the margin. By increasing the penalties for being caught committing litter or petty theft, you have lowered the cost (i.e. lowered the the marginal penalty) for armed robbery or for murdering someone who catches you in the act of littering! When a petty thief decides to commit the crime of armed robbery, he is not likely thinking about the penalty for armed robbery or murder, he is likely thinking about the extra penalty for being an armed robber conditional on him already being caught as a robber. Therefore when we attempt to get really serious about prosecuting and penalizing petty criminals, our efforts might backfire into creating a more violent society, since the cost of committing armed robbery and murder is now lower, at the margin.
Similarly, raising the penalty for littering to the death penalty will increase the incentives for litterers to shoot anyone that might possibly have seen them litter! If the penalty for murder is death and the penalty for litter is death, there is no additional cost for shooting someone, conditional on you littering. But there is a benefit! By shooting possible witnesses, you have reduced your chances of being found out.
Therefore, even though society hates litter and petty theft, instituting the death penalty for those actions might not be in their best interest. This way of thinking lends itself nicely to a whole host of interesting empirical tests, one of which I will discuss tomorrow.
Excellent illustration of marginal costs. I look forward to tomorrow’s lesson. And by God, if anyone sees me leaving dog poop in the park in the universe you describe, s/he’s in for a rude surprise!
[…] Comments « Murder at the Margin […]
986852 431104The leading source for trustworthy and timely health and medical news and data. 972885
574216 741509Glad to be 1 of numerous visitants on this awing web internet site : D. 734880
753198 13297Fantastic post, I conceive site owners need to learn a good deal from this internet blog its rattling user genial . 14470
844988 144914very good post, i surely adore this fabulous internet site, persist with it 49555
741231 844031I believe other web site owners ought to take this internet site as an model, extremely clean and wonderful user pleasant pattern . 114114
623571 512278Considerably, the story is in reality the greatest on this noteworthy subject. I agree along with your conclusions and will eagerly watch forward to your next updates. Saying good 1 will not just be sufficient, for the fantastic clarity within your writing. I will immediately grab your rss feed to stay privy of any updates! 546431
556583 428477This really is a good topic to talk about. Sometimes I fav stuff like this on Redit. This article probably wont do properly with that crowd. I will likely be certain to submit something else though. 588856
655411 449931The good intreguing articles keep me coming back here time and time once more. thank you so considerably. 79835
81631 517254I got what you intend, saved to fav, quite good website . 527451
999950 317291really nice publish, i surely really like this web web site, carry on it 266900