Feed on
Posts
Comments

The 400 Club

I don’t know whether economics or climate reporting produces the most garbage. Here’s today’s candidate for “best” article of the week:

He contends temperatures have not risen since 1998, which was unusually hot.

Temperature records contradict that claim. Both 2005 and 2010 were warmer than 1998, and the entire decade of 2000 to 2009 was the warmest on record, according to NOAA.

No it does not contradict the claim. Both can be, and are in fact, true. Average global temperatures (statistically – remember these things are measured with error, assuming there is even a correct concept as a global temperature) have been flat since 1998. And the last decade indeed was the hottest decade in the measured instrument record. The reporter knows this. He could have mentioned two things. First that if 1998 was the hottest year on record to that point, if temperatures are flat at 1998 levels for the next 12 years, then the average temperatures over the next 12 years have to be higher than the 1998 record. Second, he could have indicated what “record” means. Does it mean the paleo-record? If he does, he is wrong. If he means the instrumental record, it would be correct.

By the way, notice that he adds in to the 1998 point, “which was unusually hot” which is I think correct and valid. Of course the fact that the hottest year has not been exceeded in subsequent averages sort of contradicts what folks have been telling us. But that’s not that important. Where are all of the other caveats in the article, like, “we have no idea how to model climate?” Or even better, “the temperature record starts in the 19th century, which was unusually cold.” I don’t know if the 19th century was unusually cold for several reasons, but if it was unusually cold then the same implication the author is making regarding the last decade holds for the last 150 years but in the opposite direction — this is why the hockey stick debate is so important. Also notice – if 1998 was “unusually” hot … what does that say about climate variability? If you were pushing AGW as a major problem, wouldn’t that point work against you?

There are a few other goodies in the article. Enjoy it.

11 Responses to “The 400 Club”

  1. Harry says:

    Matter-of-factly he says it has been 800,000 years since we cracked the 0.004 percent level anywhere in the world.

    I wonder how the NOAA scientists take those readings. I mean, how do you avoid contaminating your sample, if your lab is an igloo? I’d like to know if the NOAA scientists could hold up being cross-examined by Barry Scheck.

  2. Harry says:

    The crickets are deafening, WC.

  3. sagame says:

    748985 205503I like this website its a master peace ! Glad I identified this on google . 879701

  4. 926203 29410I want to start a weblog but would like to own the domain. Any tips how to go about this?. 902507

  5. 526508 965847An intriguing discussion is worth comment. Im certain that you just write regarding this subject, might possibly not be considered a taboo topic but typically persons are too little to communicate on such topics. To another. Cheers 677556

  6. 760106 857711The urge to gamble is so universal and its practice so pleasurable, that I assume it must be evil. – Heywood Broun 31460

  7. pgslot says:

    266846 178321What a lovely weblog. Ill undoubtedly be back. Please preserve writing! 48595

  8. trusted link says:

    234420 254079Hey this really is kinda of off topic but I was wanting to know if blogs use WYSIWYG editors or should you have to manually code with HTML. Im starting a weblog soon but have no coding experience so I wanted to get advice from someone with experience. Any aid would be greatly appreciated! 589634

  9. mijnhor says:

    9927 272304I believe this web web site has some rattling amazing information for everybody : D. 164872

  10. pin-up apk says:

    175354 214144Hello! Someone in my Facebook group shared this web site with us so I came to appear it more than. Im certainly enjoying the information. Im book-marking and will probably be tweeting this to my followers! Outstanding weblog and superb style and design. 36543

  11. 530653 800050When I saw this page was like wow. Thanks for putting your effort in publishing this post. 95858

Leave a Reply