We’ll dig down into this Current Affairs vituperation of Trump’s choice of Education Secretary in some more detail later (I’m off to class now). But two points in this article I’d like to make quite clearly and simply. The author starts out by trying to understand and articulate (in true Turing Test fashion) what the arguments made by proponents of school choice are. And then he goes off the rails.
- Is this the Mount Rushmore of Straw Men or what?
“Introducing a profit motive into schooling offers a powerful incentive for schools to offer a great product. If there is money to be made on being a good school, you can bet businesses will want to provide great schools. Thus private, for-profit schools with vouchers are a highly efficient way of delivering the best-quality education.”
Now, I spent my early career in economics studying the differences between private and public schools, and enmeshing myself in the literature at the time. Where does this Duex ex Machina of FOR PROFIT come from? The argument in favor of school choice is not an argument for running schools for profit. If it turns out that this is what people end up wanting, so be it – but the argument for school choice is exactly that. Allow choices of schools. Allow choices among “public” schools. Allow a diversity of teaching and education methods across schools. Separate government funding and support for schooling from government operation of schooling. Now, I happen to think the author is not quite right on the concerns about the incentives of for-profit schools, but let’s grant that. To introduce vouchers and choice is NOT at all the same as suggesting we create a network of for-profit schools. There are thousands of Catholic schools around the country that are clearly not run for-profit. And think of how choice works in the college sector. What share of overall student enrollments end up in “for-profit” schools (I actually think schools like my own are “for-profit” and should be taxed, but that is for another day). Virtually none, despite what the news hysteria may lead you to believe. So, now that we start with a totally disingenuous argument about the purpose of school choice, it’s hard to consider the rest.
2. He ends the piece with:
“Introducing an incentive to make money will necessarily mean exploiting and neglecting the poor, whose “choices” are highly constrained by their circumstances. I fear privatization not because of some mystical devotion to the inefficiencies of government but because I fear the erosion of the idea of education as something that isn’t win-win, that we give to children because they deserve it rather than because we can profit from it. I worry that the sort of people who run things “like a business” do not really care about children very much, and are motivated by the wrong incentives. I am concerned about what would happen if they ever faced a choice between doing the right thing and doing the lucrative thing. It seems a fragile and fantastical (almost religious) hope to think that a market for schools will produce good schools rather than simply a new means for parasitic corporations to engorge themselves on government money. However bad our public schools may be, I will always trust those who see children as an ends above those who see them as a means.”
Well, considering the straw man in quote 1, I suppose I can’t begrudge the thoughts in quote 2. But that said, we are now living in a world where intentions matter. Well, excuse me while I clear the vomit out of my mouth. Who the heck gets to say that the intentions of the current government schooling monopoly are anything other than exactly the same fragile and fantastical hope that government provision of schools sees kids as ends. Is there ANY evidence that government employees, government schools, educrats and the like see kids as anything other than means? Would there be fewer motivated people who care about kids in a private school system? In my Catholic grammar and high schools, the clergy who taught us took preposterous low pay to fulfill their vocations – I can’t imagine any group of people being more committed to seeing the kids develop and as ends to be cared about rather than a means to something else. I suppose Sister Margaret can be accused of seeing me as an easy means to make her way quickly through the pearly gates – but if you want to go down that path, then tell me how the motivated passionate public school teacher who loves children is any different?
I’m sorry folks, but this sort of argument, if that is what you call it, is what is driving the divide in this country. And this guy wants it that way. I will not soften my view on that.
I address all of his other points in various other posts here at TUW, I’ll send up links to those later on.
1. Scott Alexander has an interesting post on his blog today responding to this article: http://slatestarcodex.com/2016/12/02/contra-robinson-on-schooling/
He doesn’t allude to the strawman you point to in point 1 above, although does hint that it wouldn’t hurt for Nathan Robinson to read a textbook on Public Choice.
2. “The argument in favor of school choice is not an argument for running schools for profit.”
“Separate government funding and support for schooling from government operation of schooling.”
I have found that a remarkably large number of people seem to really struggle to grasp this point.
I remember trying to have a discussion with some of my friends on Facebook about government versus private provision of medical care. I explicitly stated up front that I wanted to separate the questions of who pays for the medical care and who provides the medical care. All but two of my interlocutors failed to see the distinction or why one would want to make such a distinction. Most of the arguments that were presented in response to the question “Why is the government best placed to run hospitals?” were arguments in favour of ‘government’ (read ‘taxpayer’) funding of hospitals, rather than government administration of hospitals.
Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me? https://accounts.binance.com/pl/register-person?ref=YY80CKRN
I will immediately snatch your rss as I can not to find your email subscription link or e-newsletter service.Do you have any? Please permit me know in order that I could subscribe.Thanks.
I don’t think the title of your article matches the content lol. Just kidding, mainly because I had some doubts after reading the article.
469877 244312The most effective and clear News is really significantly imptortant to us. 176760
Mexican Easy Pharm: Mexican Easy Pharm – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
FineScan 會在肌膚上製造數以千計的細小深入傷口，即所謂的顯微加熱區（microthermal zone），但要確保每次治療時皆有部份組織不受能量影響，於是，每一個顯微加熱區的作用雖然強烈而明顯，但周圍都包覆著正常且結構完整的皮膚組織，使傷口能在短時間內癒合，並替換之前有缺陷的受損組織。Finescan不僅可讓表皮新生，更可促進深層膠原再生，從內而外徹底喚醒細胞，瞬時找回年輕時的肌膚狀態。憑藉最新的雙軸技術，FINESCAN 6可治療 – 面部 – 頸部 – 暗瘡凹凸洞 – 增生性疤痕
I think this is a real great article.Much thanks again. Want more.
435896 735727 warning Dont any of you individuals ever take me to CiCis pizza! There food looks offensive!|Urban_Elegance| 385935
Ali this was hands down my favorite write up. I love everything that brand stands for. Felicdad Conway Yeh
Hello, you used to write magnificent, but the last several posts have been kinda boring… I miss your great writings. Past several posts are just a bit out of track! come on!
434675 602835Some actually quality posts on this site , saved to favorites . 736003
Really appreciate you sharing this blog.Much thanks again. Want more.
Im obliged for the article.Really thank you! Want more.
I value the article.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.
Major thankies for the article post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Cool.
I really enjoy the blog article.Much thanks again. Really Cool.
Thank you for your article. Keep writing.
Im thankful for the blog article.Much thanks again. Much obliged.
Thank you for your article post.Thanks Again. Fantastic.
A round of applause for your blog.Much thanks again. Really Great.
Thanks-a-mundo for the post.Really thank you! Great.
Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic article post. Really Cool.
Im thankful for the blog article.Really thank you! Great.
Regards. A good amount of posts! antibiotic doxycycline
Enjoyed every bit of your blog post.Thanks Again. Cool.
magnificent put up, very informative. I wonder why the other experts of thissector do not notice this. You must proceed your writing.I’m sure, you’ve a huge readers’ base already!
Thanks-a-mundo for the post.Much thanks again.
Thanks for the blog.Much thanks again. Awesome.
Enjoyed every bit of your article. Cool.
Great, thanks for sharing this blog post.Thanks Again. Awesome.
Very neat blog.Much thanks again. Will read on…
This is one awesome article.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.
A big thank you for your article.Really thank you! Fantastic.
I think this is a real great article post.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on…
I really liked your blog.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on…
local milfspassion puzzle dating simulator photos
Thank you for your article post.Really thank you! Cool.
439846 13650hello very good web site i will definaely come back and see once more. 849225
wow, awesome article.Much thanks again. Great.
Very informative blog article.Really thank you! Great.
wow, awesome article post.Thanks Again. Cool.
Really enjoyed this blog. Keep writing.
Really enjoyed this article post.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.
Great, thanks for sharing this post.Thanks Again. Great.
Very good article. Really Great.
A round of applause for your article. Fantastic.
hi!,I really like your writing so so much! proportion we keep in touch more approximately your article on AOL? I require an expert in this space to solve my problem. Maybe that is you! Taking a look ahead to see you.
Thanks-a-mundo for the blog article.Really thank you! Really Cool.
Great remarkable things here. I am very satisfied to see your post. Thank you so much and i’m looking ahead to contact you. Will you please drop me a mail?
Very neat blog post. Really Great.
I loved your blog.Much thanks again.
Great post. I was checking continuously this blog and I’m impressed! Very helpful information specifically the last part I care for such information much. I was seeking this particular info for a long time. Thank you and good luck.
Very good article.Much thanks again. Cool.
A big thank you for your article.Thanks Again. Fantastic.
I value the blog article.Really thank you! Awesome.
639675 570096I havent checked in here for some time because I thought it was obtaining boring, but the last couple of posts are actually excellent quality so I guess Ill add you back to my daily bloglist. You deserve it my friend. insurance guides 228821
Thanks designed for sharing such a pleasantidea, piece of writing is pleasant, thats why i haveread it entirely
Aw, this was a really good post. Taking a few minutes and actual effort to make a top notch articleÖ but what can I sayÖ I procrastinate a lot and don’t seem to get anything done.
Very neat blog article. Awesome.
Major thanks for the blog article.Much thanks again. Really Great.
Thank you ever so for you post.Thanks Again. Really Great.
Great blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Great.
Looking forward to reading more. Great article post. Will read on…
Hello there! I know this is kind of off topic but I waswondering if you knew where I could find a captcha plugin for my comment form?I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’mhaving trouble finding one? Thanks a lot!
Great post.Really thank you! Great.
Enjoyed every bit of your blog article. Will read on…
Enjoyed every bit of your article.Really looking forward to read more. Really Cool.
Thanks a lot for the article post.Really thank you! Keep writing.
Thanks so much for the blog article. Will read on…
Very neat article post.Thanks Again. Will read on…
Im obliged for the blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.
I loved your blog.Really thank you! Really Cool.
I want to to thank you for this good read!! I definitely loved every little bit of it. I’ve got you book marked to check out new things you post…
Thank you ever so for you blog. Will read on…
Thanks a lot for the post.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on…
I’ll right away seize your rss as I can’t in finding your e-mail subscription hyperlink or newsletter service.Do you’ve any? Kindly allow me recognize in order that I may subscribe.Thanks.
Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.
A big thank you for your article post.Thanks Again. Keep writing.
When I originally commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get three e-mails withthe same comment. Is there any way you can remove me from that service?Cheers!
Really appreciate you sharing this article. Keep writing.
You actually mentioned it wonderfully.service essay writing the perfect thesis statement writing help for students
My brother recommended I might like this blog. He was entirely right.This post truly made my day. You cann’t imagine just how much timeI had spent for this info! Thanks!
Major thanks for the article.Really looking forward to read more. Great.
Woh I your blog posts, saved to bookmarks!My blog post low-carb diets popular
Thanks again for the article.Really thank you! Keep writing.
I do not even know how I ended up here, but I assumedthis submit was great. I do not realize who you are but certainly you are going to a well-known blogger when you aren’t already.Cheers!My blog Exam Material typically