Suppose you were put on a governmental commission to design a “green-energy” power plant that could convert our organic garbage into steam power, and produce no by-products at all.
It is not a matter of opinion to decide the minimum temperature you need to get the water in the system heated to in order to produce steam. If water is 150 degrees Fahrenheit, you get a pot of really hot water. If water is 600 degrees Fahrenheit, you might have expended too much energy to heat it up that much (maybe not). But we know, as scientists, (making simple assumptions about atmospheric pressure and a few other factors) that water needs to be heated to at least 212 degrees Fahrenheit before it starts to boil and turn into steam.
If it was popularly believed that we needed to boil water to 3400 degrees Fahrenheit, would you be alarmed? Would policymakers be alarmed? That’s more than an order of magnitude wrong! In fact, 3400 degrees is hot enough to melt virtually any metal you can think of. Gold melts at around 2000 degrees. Iron at 2800 degrees. Titanium at 3300 degrees.
And I was asking about water. Imagine the cost of the stoves we would produce if we based manufacturing standards on this information! Imagine the destruction they would inflict! Imagine how we would go about designing our new green energy plant using this as the basis of our knowledge.
Yet, this is exactly the way we make economic policy in this country. This is not to single any one out, but when I queried my students about what portion of the American labor force earned the minimum wage or less, I received far more answers above 50% than I did below 10%. The median answer was certainly well more than an order of magnitude off (probably around 50%). The latest data indicate that 1.73 million workers earned the minimum wage or less in 2007. The labor force was roughly 153 million people in 2007. So, the share of the American labor force earning the minimum wage is roughly 1.1%. ONE POINT ONE PERCENT. Not 60 percent, or 50 percent or even 10 percent. Another way to state it is that roughly half a percent of all Americans have a job and are in a job that pays minimum wage or less (ignore WHO makes the minimum wage for the time being). So, for every 200 people you randomly meet in a given day, one of them is likely to have a job paying minimum wage or less.
One of my fine colleagues likes to say that sometimes what we call “beliefs” are actually nothing of the sort. Because by holding those “beliefs” you are doing so without any cost to yourself. For example, what is the significance of putting a “Free Tibet” bumper sticker on your car? Are you planning in starting a war with China? Do you send all of your savings to Tibetan freedom-fighters? If Tibet stays unfree are you at any risk? So saying that you want to free Tibet is something other than a belief, for it is a completely costless statement to you.
So, how am I to characterize the popular notions of American wage earners? Are these beliefs? Or are these something else. If the political process is as demented and effective as some think it is, then sadly, these are actual beliefs. Wrong as they may be, the very people who will select candidates on populist grounds will end up promoting policies that put themselves and their friends and family on the unemployment line, or worse. Of course, the people who are actually making these claims are not likely to be the same people who are earning the minimum wage, or who are at risk for earning the minimum wage – so we are back into non-belief land again. There are no consequences to themselves for holding these beliefs.
This is a huge market failure. Many people hold ideas about economic facts that bear no resemblance to truth. They can hold these ideas because they do not themselves bear the costs of these ideas. However, there are enormous consequences of these ideas being widely held. Horrible policy gets put into place that puts the people most at risk for bad economic outcomes into even more dire straights – and then they blame “the system” for it. Furthermore, these ideas lead to policies that very likely could diminish economic growth going forward, much to the detriment of future generations, who do not have an agent today to represent their interests. These bad ideas are like communal property in that regard. The interests of the current generation are far more heavily weighted than “ought” to be.
Of course, the preferred solution to market failure, particularly among the kind of folks that label themselves “Progressive” is for the government to get involved and make the appropriate corrections. What types of corrections would remedy this problem? Mandate that every American be forced to sit through several of my economics lectures (hmmm … I can imagine myself forming an organization to lobby for that … for the public good, right?). You don’t like that idea? Then how about a tax on bad ideas. Imagine your worries then! Who gets to decide what is a bad idea? Who gets to decide how much the appropriate tax should be? And who is responsible when the program fails? Or succeeds?
This is just the tip of the iceberg. How are we to effectively convey important economic principles when there is such widespread and persistent misunderstanding of facts? I raise this point because often after I present the relevant data, the response is shrugged shoulders and a comment under the breath about me being an evil, greedy capitalist tool for corporate America. Ask folks why they hold these ideas … and inevitably it will be because someone told them this was the case, or they watch too much TV.
I certainly do not think these ideas are held because of innocent ignorance. How could it be? My guess is that people have more direct experience in their daily lives with interacting with wage earners than they do with boiling water. Yet ask most people what temperature boils at, and if they cannot give you a precise answer, they will be in the ballpark. The same is not true of economic data.
I should have gone hiking today.
It’s too late for me to laud this post with the accolades that it deserves. Suffice it to say that you succinctly state what I’ve believed since I’ve lived a while.
I enjoyed this survey.
This survey was very interesting in its showing of the misconceptions in the “beliefs” of the average American. It really makes you think.
I had no idea Americans held so many misconceptions.
The whole time i was reading this article, all i kept thinking about was the book “Whats the Matter with Kansas”. A book about why Kansas continuously votes republican even though voting democratic is more in line with what they want economically.
I enjoyed the survey. It really made me think about a lot of interesting issues.
The survey had several fact-based questions which your average informed college student would have no idea about, myself included.
There were also several subjective questions which forced a libertarian agenda, by pointing out consequences that people hadn’t thought of. But aren’t there other consequences, still unconsidered, which might not suggest such a libertarian approach to the American economy?
Great Survey. I probably got at least half the questions wrong, shows you that there are so many important questions out there about our society and people don’t even think about it. Hopefully now I find out the real answers.
This survey was really eye-opening. The extent of American’s misconceptions and their effect on policy is surprising and also disturbing. It makes me wonder how much more efficient and successful our nation would be if they were reduced.
Well, I need a lot to learn about the economy. . .
Aced it, yay google.
8stzlx
z11nyf
dfgtks
2c16gs
sdq9cj
nanz7f
s5yud7
Ensure precise control over your material properties with our precise roller ball mills.
Mixers that cater to specific industries – we’ll provide you with tailored specifications upon request.
I just couldn’t leave your web site before suggesting that I extremely loved the usual information a person provide on your guests? Is going to be again incessantly to inspect new posts
Thee other day, while I was at work, myy cosin stole mmy apple ipd and tested to see iff itt can survivfe a forty
folt drop, just so shhe cann bee a youtibe sensation. My aapple ipoad is noww destroyed
and shhe hhas 83 views. I knhow this is totally off topic bbut I hadd tto
share it with someone!
Hello! Would you mind if I share your blog with my twitter group? There’s a lot of folks that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Many thanks
What i don’t realize is in fact how you’re now not really a lot more well-appreciated than you may be now. You are so intelligent. You understand therefore considerably with regards to this matter, made me in my view believe it from a lot of numerous angles. Its like men and women are not fascinated until it is something to accomplish with Woman gaga! Your individual stuffs outstanding. All the time maintain it up!
Your style is so unique compared to many other people. Thank you for publishing when you have the opportunity,Guess I will just make this bookmarked.2
I go to seee eery dayy somme web pages and websites too read posts, except this webb sitge gives feature baswd writing.
434350 414761This sort of in search of get the enhancements produced on this particular lifestyle and diet, begin your L . a . Shifting the pounds diet answer can be a huge procedure into accesing which typically hope. weight loss 171451
I likewise think so , perfectly indited post! .
738521 44933Dead written subject matter, Truly enjoyed reading via . 289282
glu23l
Yes! Finallyy somethingg about 14719.
Muchas gracias. ?Como puedo iniciar sesion?
99395 88873hey there, your web site is fantastic. I do thank you for function 768136
Does your site have a contact page? I’m having problems locating it but, I’d like to shoot you an email. I’ve got some creative ideas for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great site and I look forward to seeing it improve over time.
I believe this site holds some real good information for everyone :D. “Time–our youth–it never really goes, does it It is all held in our minds.” by Helen Hoover Santmyer.
This iss my first tim pay a quick vusit aat hefe and i amm realoy happy to reead everthkng aat onee place.
I’m nnot that mich of a internet reader to be honest bbut
your sites rrally nice, keep iit up! I’ll goo ahead and booikmark
your siite to come back inn thee future. Cheers
My husband and i ended up being absolutely delighted Michael managed to conclude his researching from your precious recommendations he received through the site. It’s not at all simplistic just to happen to be releasing helpful hints other folks have been trying to sell. And we all realize we need the blog owner to thank for this. Most of the illustrations you’ve made, the simple blog menu, the friendships your site assist to create – it is all great, and it’s assisting our son in addition to our family reason why this idea is enjoyable, and that’s extremely indispensable. Many thanks for all!
Thank you for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbor were just preparing to do some research on this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more clear from this post. I’m very glad to see such excellent information being shared freely out there.
My coder iis trying to convince mme to ove to .net ftom PHP.
I hae always dislijked the idea because oof thhe expenses.
Buut he’s tryiong nne tthe less. I’ve besen using Movable-type on a vriety of
websites ffor about a year andd aam worried ablut switching too another platform.
I have heard good things aabout blogengine.net.
Is thsre a wway I can transfer aall my wordpres content into it?
Any help wold bee greatly appreciated!
Excellent post. I wass checkking continuousy thiss blog annd I am
impressed! Veery seful information specifically thee
last pazrt 🙂 I care ffor such infto a lot. I was seeking this partticular informaqtion forr a long time.
Thqnk yyou and good luck.
333990 342040The website loading velocity is incredible. 402753
I doo believe alll tthe ideeas youu have presented on yiur post.
They’re very convijcing and wiull certainnly work.
Still, the powts aare too shoirt forr starters. Maay jusst
you pleazse lengthen them a bit from subsequent time?
Thank you for thee post.
623580 26373replica watches are remarkable reproduction of original authentic swiss luxury time pieces. 457858