Apparently, that is what you are if you dare question anything about the educational system. In a book review I am writing on Goldin and Katz’s Race Between Education and Technology, I dared to say:
The existing K12 system cannot be improved until the political class recognizes the success of various school choice programs and honestly assesses the shocking lack of productivity and entrepreneurship within the sector
The editor responded:
A substantive comment on which you do not have to act: I think your strong claim in the previous sentence (“This will be increasingly difficult…”) is not very well supported by this sentence (“The existing K12 system…”), which states as a given, with no evidence, that (a) some school choice programs work, (b) the existing K12 sector is shockingly lacking in productivity and entrepreneurship, and (c) the “political class” fails to recognize those facts. These two sentences together will, I bet, alienate some readers (not me! -I have no opinions on the matter) unless the argument is beefed up a little, because they come across as churlish. But as I said, you don’t have to add anything–nor do you need to respond to this note. Thank you.]
The review is rather long, and we are instructed not to include long literature reviews, but that seems to be what the comment called for. I am not upset with the editor, not at all, but I think part of what is wrong with education in America is exemplified by this kind of response. Note that the only two substantive comments on the piece were in places where what I said would make an educational professional with an unconstrained vision squirm in his chair.
62277 721415What is your most noted accomplishment. They could want great listeners rather than great talkers. 314746
375746 265119Following study numerous the websites along with your internet site now, and that i genuinely appreciate your method of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and are checking back soon. Pls have a look at my internet page likewise and let me know if you agree. 858740
239146 177732Nice read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing a little research on that. And he actually bought me lunch as I found it for him smile Therefore let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch! 411514
709034 576387Your talent is truly appreciated!! Thank you. You saved me a lot of frustration. I switched from Joomla to Drupal to the WordPress platform and Ive fully embraced WordPress. Its so a lot easier and easier to tweak. Anyway, thanks once again. Awesome domain! 846637
972129 754187I cant say that I completely agree, but then again Ive never really thought of it quite like that before. Thanks for giving me something to take into consideration when Im supposed to have an empty mind while trying to fall asleep tonight lol.. 837118
808402 301638Sweet site , super layout, actually clean and utilize genial . 381665