Radio ads here in Rochester have been touting the “new” employment tax credits that have come from Washington, DC. The idea is that for firms that hire currently unemployed workers and keep them employed for a long-enough time period, they will receive a credit on their tax liabilities. Let’s not think of the labor economics of this for the time being. I just want you to think of the normative implications here.
For this tax to be funded, it has to be the case that currently profitable firms are paying taxes. These firms are possibly the very same firms that had runs of good luck, or behaved prudently, etc. so that they have been profitable through the down-turn. These firms in fact are very likely to be the ones that did the most hiring during the downturn, or that preserved employees even if it came at some expense to them. What we are effectively doing is penalizing these successful firms, these firms that have already hired workers, to make payments to less successful firms who either laid off workers during the recession, or were never profitable enough to encourage hiring. In other words, as we are prone to do in the Progressive paradise, our employment tax credit policy is a penalty to the successful job producing firms to the benefit of the unsuccessful non-job producers.
Maybe you think this is a good idea, and indeed I can conjure up a lovely labor economic model to support it. But before you get too excited, think about the long term consequences of that.
You are a firm in the year 2015 and the economy is entering a downturn. You have the choice of laying off workers or you can keep them on at some cost to you, so that you will be well positioned to make profits when the recession ends. Now that you have seen past government behavior lower the cost to firms of hiring workers in a recession, the scales have been tipped in favor of releasing workers. In addition, the tax burden placed upon firms because of this behavior has to be larger than if we never offered employment tax credits. In other words, the benefits of keeping workers on and productive are smaller as well. So, we have a case where the benefits of keeping workers are lower and the costs of releasing workers are lower, what do you think might happen during the next downturn? It would not be too much to suspect that the downturn would be faster and deeper than the previous one. So aside from the obvious bizarre asymmetry of the initial act, in the long-run it can very well lead to more of the very problem it was intended to solve.
291207 15672 Spot on with this write-up, I truly feel this site needs considerably far more consideration. Ill probably be once again to read significantly a lot more, thanks for that information. 60126
159342 121094Depending on yourself to make the decisions can genuinely be upsetting and frustrating. It takes years to build confidence. Frankly it takes more than just happening to happen. 63365
334374 25418Truly clear internet website , thanks for this post. 509625
366377 891019I always pay a visit to your blog and retrieve everything you post here but I never commented but today when I saw this post, I couldnt stop myself from commenting here. Fantastic article mate! 695739
332846 922137Wonderful humans speeches and toasts, possibly toasts. are hands down transferred at some time by way of party and expected to turn into quite funny, amusing not to mention educational in the mean time. best man wedding speeches 525892
6792 734623Wow, superb weblog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging appear effortless. The overall look of your internet site is magnificent, as properly as the content material! xrumer 311172
498406 135253Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So good to search out any individual with some original thoughts on this topic. realy thank you for starting this up. this site is 1 thing thats wanted on the web, somebody with a bit of originality. beneficial job for bringing something new to the internet! 184674
774473 824506Thankyou for all your efforts which you have put in this. really fascinating information . 52473
48587 929555Be the precise weblog in the event you have wants to learn about this topic. You comprehend considerably its nearly onerous to argue to you (not that I personally would needHaHa). You undoubtedly put a new spin for a subject thats been discussing for some time. Nice stuff, merely good! 252080