And no, I am not directing the “you” at anyone in particular. I apologize if this seems a crass attack, but it is not ad hominem. A few days ago, Professor Landsburg offered the insight that replacing Medicare spending with vouchers would reduce spending on medical care in the long run. How? Well, if instead of someone else footing the bill when I went to the doctor, that same amount of money would be provided to me in the form of a voucher, and given that most of us are rational, economizing beings, at the margin we would be more selective about the amount and type of medical treatment we consume.
My readers would not be surprised by this insight. But the rest of America seems to be. Read the comments to his post or on Krugman’s blogs on this topic. A few random observations:
- The “Progressives” pan this plan and any one resembling it as a matter of religion. If it were floated by Barbara Boxer, would they still pan it? Now, if Boxer ever proposed something like it, I would support it – much like I am supportive of what our Progressive Governor Andrew Cuomo has been trying to do in NY. I don’t care if an alien from Mars came down and decided it was time to recognize unicorns don’t exist, I would support a person who started from that understanding regardless of their affiliation.
- The “Progressives” (wrongly in my view) argue that spending on health care is a problem. Well, it is only a problem when people are spending other people’s money. Would they argue that since Wintercow spends over 16% of his disposable income on schooling for his children, and that this number has increased at faster than the rate of inflation over the past 4 years, that there is a crisis on our hands? But if spending is a problem, aside from the few good pieces of the ObamaCare legislation which would likely restrain cost increases a little bit, what else do they offer as a real cost reducing option. Saying “NO!” to vouchers is not exactly a way to reduce costs. Or do they think that further state-ifying health care will magically reduce costs. Even if it did reduce money costs, the total costs of such a world are not likely to differ much from today’s, they may even be worse.
- Here are my real issues. If the “Progressives” like to argue that “we spend all this money in the US and we get no better outcomes than the rest of the (preferred) world,” it is not possible to argue in the next breath that offering Medicare recipients vouchers is going to be a crisis. Why? Well, if seniors “stupidly” cannot make medical choices on their own, then not getting needed health care will not be a problem – that’s the point of the argument of “we spend too much.” And if you want to argue that seniors are not stupid, then giving them vouchers rather than the government paying doctors directly cannot possibly increase costs as compared to the status quo. So to argue that, “we should not do it because it might not reduce costs” is a total red herring.
- I politely ask, “what is the evidence that more consumer involvement via vouchers would NOT have the impacts Professor Landsburg is mentioning?” Ought the burden of proof be on folks that start with the assumption that individuals are NOT economizers? But it seems that the “Progressives” have won the discussion by somehow making the burden of proof fall on people who know unicorns do not exist.
- I am rather astounded by the “outrage” at the Ryan plan. Consider a plan where the government, today, spends the same amount of money targeting medical insurance support to its citizens. What these vouchers are talking about is putting more power in the hands of individuals. It is intended to reduce the rate of cost increase to government to get the same or better medical outcomes. So what opponents seem to be grossly arguing is that no government policy is acceptable unless it is RUN by the government. Don’t go parading around talking about health outcomes or anything else as cover for this view. It reminds me of the “environmentalists” who are aghast! that the Chinese government is subsidizing green energy technologies. It ain’t about the environment for them, nor is this Medicare dust-up about health for these people. Sorry, play again some other day.
Muchas gracias. ?Como puedo iniciar sesion?
202030 289754It is not that I want to duplicate your website, but I truly like the style. Could you tell me which style are you employing? Or was it custom produced? 435396
773968 749613Glad to be one of numerous visitants on this awful internet site : D. 988021
82073 572890I observe there is a lot of spam on this weblog. Do you need assist cleaning them up? I may support among classes! 463073
267291 235673I believe other internet site owners really should take this web site as an example , very clean and fantastic user genial style . 16108
320866 234178I cannot thank you fully for the blogposts on your internet page. I know you placed lots of time and effort into all of them and hope you know how considerably I appreciate it. I hope I will do precisely exactly the same for yet another individual at some point. Palm Beach Condos 821467
769750 120365I recognize theres lots of spam on this web site. Do you require aid cleansing them up? I may aid among courses! 180004
84751 946998I appreciate you taking the time to create this post. It has been genuinely valuable to me definitely. Value it. 230252
880257 551434This is genuinely intriguing, You are a really skilled blogger. Ive joined your rss feed and appear forward to seeking much more of your magnificent post. Also, Ive shared your internet internet site in my social networks! 128222
401246 294793Outstanding post, I feel weblog owners need to larn a good deal from this web site its rattling user friendly . 577326
658738 320924I conceive this internet site has got some real wonderful details for everybody : D. 401087
268875 923823This is a fantastic blog, would you be interested in doing an interview regarding how you created it? If so e-mail me! 386465
28641 815569Lovely sharp post. Never considered that it was that easy. Praises to you! 585662
136920 667004Aw, this was a extremely good post. In thought I want to put in writing like this moreover ?taking time and actual effort to make a extremely great write-up?even so what can I say?I procrastinate alot and undoubtedly not appear to get one thing done. 871335
798266 772216Youre so appropriate. Im there with you. Your blog is surely worth a read if anyone comes throughout it. Im lucky I did because now Ive obtained a complete new view of this. I didnt realise that this issue was so critical and so universal. You absolutely put it in perspective for me. 944228