A student of mine was upset about some actions of a corporation he learned about in a Law class here. His immediate conclusion to me was, “this is why we need socialism.” Now, I am almost sure that folks who say this don’t actually know what socialism is, nor are they prepared to discuss the history of it, or the economics of it. In case you wish to have a discussion on issues like this (and others) there is a really fruitful and simple way to proceed.
How?
Just ask the person a question. “I can respect why you think this. But can you do me a favor? Can you imagine getting your ideal world in place, and then rather than “your guys” being in charge, how would you feel if the person/people running it were people you completely mistrusted, despised and disagreed with? Would you feel good about your system? Why or why not?”
I am sure you’ll have an interesting conversation. I thank Bryan Caplan for discussing this. I remember reading him some time ago on his invaluable Museum of Communism site.
Bravo, you of course nailed it.
I often get asked, as a libertarian, why I trust private corporations more than the government, and then the person talking to me likely rattles off a long list of private bad actors (Enron is always on the list).
I respond that I do not trust private actors more than people in government. What I trust more is the incentives of private actors, and the accountability mechanisms I have over them. Enron, for example, was killed by the market long before the first government prosecutor even showed up on the scene. If I don’t like a private company, I don’t do business with it, an opt-out that is not available to me when dealing with the government.
In fact, when poor performing companies stay in business (GM) or I am forced to deal with a single monopoly (my electric service), all-too-often this is because of government intervention, not the lack of it.
1) It is a form of John Rawls’ challenge: design your perfect society… no, you do not get to pick your place in it. Here, you design your perfect society and put your enemies in charge.
2) For a graduate criminology class in Miscarriages of Justice and Wrongful Convictions, I wrote my term paper on Arthur Andersen. Their conviction was overturned on appeal, but they were dead. Being associated with Enron killed them as partners and clients fled.
Long ago, writing for Ayn Rand, Alan Greenspan praised the integrity that is required when (then) millions (now billions) of dollars in value are exchanged with a phone call. On a more mundane note, back before everthing went to http://www.com, Newt Gingrich pointed out that you dial an 800 number, talk to someone you never met, give them your credit card number, and show up at the airport actually expecting a ticket to be there waiting for you.
The fundamental morality, honesty, and integrity of the marketplace is taken for granted even by people who think they want socialism. When was the last time you saw anyone without shoes? We have no government shoe agency, no Department of Clothing, and just about all of our shoes are imported, whether from China or Italy… although, I am proud to say that my new Redwing work boots were Made in the USA.
MM, I know this is sliding a bit from WC’s topic, but it was for us, and I assume still is, not unusual to do a five-figure heifer deal on a handshake with Amish farmers.
Of course, the heifers were never loaded on the truck before the cash was handed over.
Kip’s law: “Every advocate of central planning envisions himself as the central planner.”
And then there’s Worstall’s addendum.
http://timworstall.com/2012/09/19/worstalls-addendum-to-kips-law/
Greetings! Very helpful advice in this particular post! It’s the little changes which will make the most significant changes. Thanks a lot for sharing!
Howdy, I do believe your website might be having web browser compatibility problems. When I take a look at your web site in Safari, it looks fine however, when opening in IE, it has some overlapping issues. I merely wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other than that, fantastic blog!
I just added this weblog to my google reader, great stuff. Cannot get enough!
Muchas gracias. ?Como puedo iniciar sesion?
259425 84597Thank you for your great post! It has long been extremely insightful. I hope that you will continue sharing your wisdom with us. 752808
684228 796070That is some inspirational stuff. Never knew that opinions could be this varied. Be positive to keep writing. 104060
Does your site have a contact page? I’m having problems locating it but, I’d like to send you an e-mail. I’ve got some creative ideas for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great blog and I look forward to seeing it grow over time.
Buy elite quality proxies – Completely private ELITE private proxies with TOP degree of security only from DreamProxies.com
241023 902791Its excellent as your other posts : D, regards for posting . 337941
844510 205041As I internet site possessor I think the articles here is extremely wonderful, regards for your efforts. 763086
Espectro de vibracion Sistemas de ajuste: clave para el rendimiento estable y eficiente de las equipos. En el mundo de la ciencia moderna donde la efectividad y la confiabilidad del aparato son de máxima importancia los sistemas de balanceo tienen un rol crucial. Estos sistemas especializados están diseñados para balancear y asegurar componentes móviles ya sea en equipamiento productiva transportes de movilidad o incluso en electrodomésticos de uso diario. Para los expertos en reparación de sistemas y los técnicos manejar con dispositivos de calibración es fundamental para proteger el desempeño uniforme y fiable de cualquier mecanismo móvil. Gracias a estas herramientas avanzadas innovadoras es posible limitar significativamente las movimientos el estruendo y la tensión sobre los rodamientos extendiendo la vida útil de componentes valiosos. También trascendental es el función que desempeñan los aparatos de balanceo en la servicio al comprador. El apoyo especializado y el conservación constante empleando estos sistemas facilitan dar prestaciones de alta estándar incrementando la bienestar de los compradores. Para los propietarios de proyectos la inversión en unidades de balanceo y detectores puede ser importante para incrementar la rendimiento y rendimiento de sus aparatos. Esto es particularmente importante para los emprendedores que manejan medianas y modestas negocios donde cada aspecto vale. También los sistemas de balanceo tienen una extensa uso en el ámbito de la seguridad y el control de excelencia. Permiten identificar probables defectos evitando arreglos elevadas y averías a los aparatos. Incluso los indicadores extraídos de estos dispositivos pueden aplicarse para optimizar procedimientos y incrementar la exposición en sistemas de exploración. Las zonas de utilización de los dispositivos de ajuste comprenden diversas ramas desde la manufactura de bicicletas hasta el monitoreo ecológico. No influye si se refiere de importantes fabricaciones industriales o modestos locales de uso personal los sistemas de ajuste son indispensables para proteger un rendimiento eficiente y libre de fallos.
17516 258702hi!,I like your writing so considerably! share we communicate more about your write-up on AOL? I demand an expert on this location to solve my problem. Maybe thats you! Searching forward to see you. 894561
998507 188647Lastly, got what I was seeking for!! Ive genuinely enjoying every small bit of this. Ecstatic I stumbled into this post! and also Ive bookmarked to appear at exclusive info for your weblog post. 457167
303762 68102Youd outstanding guidelines there. I did a search about the field and identified that really likely the majority will agree together with your web page. 520425
785143 302131Ich kenne einige Leute, die aus Kanadakommen. Eines Tages werde ich auch dorthin reisen Lg Daniela 298327
477150 272514Woh I like your content , saved to favorites ! . 10598
alo789 chinh th?c: alo789 chinh th?c – alo 789
106753 199735i was just browsing along and came upon your site. just wantd to say wonderful job and this post really helped me. 34229
539498 643566great post. Neer knew this, thanks for letting me know. 336322
824932 82439Thank you for your quite great data and feedback from you. car dealers in san jose 65457