Good economics recognizes that we do not produce merely for the sake of production, hobbies notwithstanding. In other words, the sole end of all production is consumption. The reason I am in here long before the break of dawn is not really because I particularly love combing through the NBER Working Papers, or that I am particularly thrilled to dive into the nuances of price sensitivity for my morning lecture, but rather because I want to make my mortgage payments. In other words, since I am not able make everything that I want for myself, I have to engage in trade with strangers in order to have them provide that stuff for me. And since we are not living in altruistic fantasy-land, most folks around the planet don’t wake up before the crack of dawn thinking of what I might want or need on that particular day — I have to persuade those folks to provide things for me by in fact delivering something to them first.
The nice part of our modern economic lives is that when I engage in this process, I still don’t have to figure out what any one particular person wants – for example, the guy who sold me my hockey stick may in fact want a bagel in exchange for it. All I have to figure out is what someone, somewhere, may want – and be willing to exchange something, somewhere for it. The extended web of human cooperation is woven tightly enough together that all I really need to do is make sure I am in the web, and be less concerned about where I am in it. There have been dozens of books written exploring this topic, and in a little more elegant style than the paragraphs above.
Today however I’d like to point out another way that consumers are producers, and one that I find to be a deeper and perhaps just as important insight. The entire process of our economic lives consists of a sort of human alchemy – transforming things that we find less valuable into those that we find more valuable. As “traditional” producers this process is ingrained in our heads as pretty straightforward. As a brewer, you get some water (sometimes treat it), you get some barley and perhaps some specialty grain, you culture some yeast, you grow some hops, and you do a little magic by transforming them into a delicious nectar called beer.
But, it’s not just as producers of goods in the product market that we act in this transformative manner. When we, as individuals, set out to consume something we are engaging in exactly the same process. Imagine you have a headache. For someone who has a headache and who wishes to be rid of it, you can argue that they are in search of “purchasing a good” by the name of “less pain in my head.” I use this example rather than a more mundane one like, “wants an orange” because I think the following point is clearer here. When I want to “eat an orange” I’m not actually seeking out the good of an orange. What I am doing is looking for a way to quench both thirst and hunger and perhaps obtain important vitamins. That an orange happens to be the good that most readily satisfies those desires obscures the fact that an orange is in fact MERELY one way to be able to do that.
The point is that an orange is not an orange. When I purchase or grow an orange for myself, I am not growing “fleshy fruit with thick skin and vitamin c inside” but rather I am growing an input into the production of something else I want, and when I consume an orange I am not really eating fleshy orange fruit. No! What I am doing is consuming the services that are provided by this physical object. Put in this way, you can see that there is not in fact any “correct’ way to consume an orange. Should one wish to play baseball with their son, an orange is definitely on the list of things that may enable us to play such a sport. Should one wish to make craft projects at home, an orange is clearly on the list of things that may enable us to do that. Should one be hungry, an orange is clearly on the list of things we can use to meet that need to. And an orange, disagree as you may, is nothing more than an idea, a possibility, an “input” into the production of some service that you wish to obtain. That you are most familiar with it being used as a way to get calories and vitamins does not mean that this is the “correct” way to consume an orange, or that this is the “purpose” of an orange.
The beauty of our human minds and our individuality is that each of uses our own minds and our own vision to determine what we would like to do with particular “resources.” This is not information that can ever be knowable by some third party, particularly of the political kind where there are neither incentives nor mechanisms to transmit that knowledge from person to person, and certainly not the incentives to get it right. Indeed, many of us don’t know this knowledge until perhaps placed in a particular position to generate it. And this is the miracle of the price system. What enables us to draw deep in our minds to seek out different and “better” ways of doing things? Is it the pleading of our moms? Is it the bleating of our bloviating buffoons in the capitol? Hardly. It is the “system” of prices that we are enmeshed in.
Think about your pained head (and I’m probably making it worse right now). How do you decide how to best deal with that head? Like it or not, prices guide our behavior here. You may be thinking about how much an Advil costs, and if it’s price is low you surely secure some immediately and pop them down with a glass of coffee and water. But at $100 per Advil, you might simply tell yourself, “It’s not worth it, I’ll figure something out.” We do this all the team. When “prices” are higher (i.e. when we have to make greater sacrifices of OTHER things to get more of THIS thing), then these tradeoffs force us to mitigate our desires, if only a little bit. And as the tradeoffs become more severe, we look ever harder for other ways to secure the services we want. There is nothing in our nature and nothing in economics that says all desires CAN be met. But what is terrific about a system of property rights and prices is that each of us is free to look at a price, a tradeoff, and ask ourselves, “are we able or willing to endure this tradeoff” in order to get the service we want. You may want to pay $100 per pill. I may not. And this may not have anything at all to do with our income. No third party is able to make these choices as well as we can. Furthermore, think about how your behavior changes as these prices increase. As Advil prices go from a penny per pill to a quarter per pill to a dollar per pill and more. You may begin looking for other ways to meet the headache straight on. Maybe you use aspirin. Maybe you take ice cubes out of the freezer and place them on your head. Maybe you pray. But how you decide is up to YOU. There is no right way to economize. But the price system forces you to do it, and it forces you to do it in a way that suits you, and does so without the use of real force. It’s ethical.
And in thinking about your headache, what you realize as the price of Advil moves around is that Advil is not the “correct” way to solve that problem. Your mileage may vary, but you should at least recognize that Advil is not Advil. What “Advil” is is at best a particular way to alleviate head pain. And once we realize that we are “purchasing” the service “alleviate head pain” then you can easily understand that there are myriad ways to do it. When I was little, my old Italian grandmother would have recommended a slap a flank steak on my head. She once sliced potatoes up and placed them around my head wrapped tightly in an old t-shirt. When other things get more expensive, then these “remedies” become more attractive. And when these remedies are inexpensive we do more of them too. So, indeed, a “flank steak is not a flank steak” either! Why? When the tradeoffs you must make to get 8 ounces of flank steak are substantial, you probably use flank steak only as a slow cooked delightful meal. But if it gets less and less expensive, you use “flank steaks” as inputs into more and more “consumer” goods. You may begin freezing some for future consumption. They get cheaper and you may buy some for your friends. They get cheaper and you may use them to feed your Boston Terriers. They get cheaper and you may use them as arts and crafts. They get cheaper and suddenly you make them a part of your home headache remedy repertoire. There is NO CORRECT way to consume a flank steak – since value is subjective and each of us sees a flank steak as an input into some other service we wish to provide for ourselves.
This insight is extraordinarily powerful.
- It informs how we think about whether “actual” producers have market power over consumers – if indeed there are myriad ways for us to satisfy wants, then the sway any one producer of one particular way of meeting those wants is far more limited than a literal description of their capabilities is. So, while there is only a single, “monopoly” seller of satellite radio services, and you may think they have massive market power over us since we have no choices about buying satellite radio, when you realize that “satellite radio is NOT satellite radio” you will also realize that it’s hard to make money, much less survive, as a seller of “satellite radio.” Why? Because they’re not selling satellite radio, they are selling one particular input into the service “music to listen to” or even more generally the service, “ways to be entertained.” And we all know full well that there are many, many other ways that we can use to meet those consumption needs.
- It informs the idea of “waste.” When you understand that there is no “right” way to consume something, waste, much like cost and value, is also subjective. You are only “wasting” something when you could have more efficiently obtained the service that you want. So, it is not wasteful to play baseball with an orange if that is the “best” way for you to meet the demand for the service, “joy of hitting a round object. That someone else objects to your hitting an orange with a bad is presupposing that there is a correct way to consume an orange, and that is as food. That’s wholly aside from the fact that we grow all kinds of things and don’t eat them – after all the bat you use to hit that orange was derived from a tree grown for that purpose – and that is no more or less wasteful than using an orange as a baseball. You object? Really. Using a tree as a baseball bat means that land cannot be used to grow oranges. And so if you accept that hitting an object with a Louisville Slugger is OK, then you are saying that “wasting food” is OK. Just because you cannot see the “wasted” orange doesn’t mean at all that it is any different. So, commands to “reduce waste” are nothing more than commands by other people to do what THEY want you to do, and not for you to do what YOU want to do. And this is wholly aside from the vastly misunderstood concept of what waste is, and whether it is a problem. Here is one particular illustration.
- You can now come to the appreciation for why central planning and socialism CANNOT work. It cannot work, not only because people are not angels and not always altruistic (I wouldn’t want to live in that world anyway). No, even in a world of angels, socialism can’t work because the knowledge requirements for it to work would choke the world’s most amazing supercomputers. It simply cannot be calculated on any human-machine interface. Ever. Just think about headaches. How would a central planner know when anyone even had a headache, or why they got it? How would it even know what is in the choice set for all people in terms of how they might deal with their headache? How would it know how each person ranks each tradeoff? How would it know where each of the ways to cure headaches is located, and what it requires to deliver them to each person? How would it know how consumers in India making choices about headache solutions impacts the availability of other solutions in Alaska? And when folks preferences or tolerances change, how would that all get transmitted to a computer, processed, and then sent back to each of us as consumers about the “best” way to solve our headache problem? And that’s just headaches, and that’s just today. Imagine this problem for tens of billions of goods and services, being constantly computed and updated and transmitted to every one of us at all times. It’s preposterous that anyone is even doing this at a Gedankin level, much less having actually inflicted this insanity on real, living, human beings.
- So our understanding of the value of prices, property rights and the market system as superior ways to organize large commercial societies does not require a morality tale, it requires only an appreciation for how complex the real world is, and an appreciation for exactly the kind of knowledge that is embedded in even the most mundane of decisions that each of us diverse individuals makes thousands of times each and every day. But it’s hard to condemn that aspect of human nature, so that’s not what “socialists” and collectivists of all stripes spend their time doing. In fact, they are the real alchemists. Focusing on the immorality of property rights and markets is worse than a red herring. Not only can we have the argument about which “institution” is more moral (is that even a correct framing?), but we don’t need to. The right argument is which institution can generate, process and transmit knowledge peacefully and efficiently – and central planning fails the test. But it’s not satisfying to talk about the limits of knowledge. So we don’t see that argument. And instead market “defenders” end up playing on the turf of those who truly are the “deniers” in the most scientific meaning of the term, much to the detriment of all of us.
You ought to sell that piece (I volunteer as one of your free proofreaders) to the WSJ, or National Review, whoever pays more, WC.
Glad you are up early to get all this work done. You are a great retired blogger.
After selling the article, use the title for the book, and make that the first chapter. Contact Charles Krauthammer’s puisher for further advice. The free proofreader holds for the book, too. I have read no good book published in the last thirty years where I have not found at least one inadvertent error.
I have been advised that the Title should be Oranges are Ideas, much better. Fits on a book.
I agree. Outstanding.
hhiz10h
cwoqtbz
j4y66z
s3g9iu
pbu32o
q88b94
x7dovj
vkq0jl
I like this web blog very much, Its a rattling nice place to read and incur information.
Leading the way in planetary ball mill production, our factory delivers excellence at affordable rates. Consultations welcome.
Hey very nihe blog!
Goood day! This is my 1st clmment here soo I just wanted
to give a quik shout out and say I genuinely enjoky readxing throug
you blog posts. Caan yoou recommenmd aany othr blogs/websites/forums
that goo over the same subjects? Thannks ffor your time!
Awesome article.
Nicce post. I used to be cecking constantly thyis blog annd I’m inspired!
Extremely hellful informatiion sspecially the last phase 🙂 I deral wih such information a lot.
I wwas looking for thjs partichlar info forr a veery lonmg time.
Tank youu and gopod luck.
Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is a really well written article. I’ll make sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I will certainly return.
I want forgathering useful info, this post has got me even more info! .
Unquestionably imagine that which you stated. Your favorite reason seemed to be on the net the simplest factor to be aware of. I say to you, I certainly get irked while folks consider concerns that they plainly do not recognise about. You controlled to hit the nail upon the top and defined out the entire thing with no need side effect , folks can take a signal. Will likely be back to get more. Thank you
Модные заметки по созданию модных луков на любой день.
Обзоры стилистов, события, все новые коллекции и шоу.
https://furluxury.ru/fur/2024-09-27-7-luchshih-sumok-jacquemus-2024-goda-stil-smelost-i-frantsuzskiy-shik/
Модные заметки по созданию превосходных видов на каждый день.
Заметки стилистов, события, все коллекции и мероприятия.
https://furluxury.ru/fur/2024-09-27-7-luchshih-sumok-jacquemus-2024-goda-stil-smelost-i-frantsuzskiy-shik/
Whhy userss still uuse tto rrad news papers whrn iin thi ttechnological world everything is available oon net?
Awsome article and straight to the point. I am not sure if this is really the best place to ask but do you guys have any thoughts on where to employ some professional writers? Thank you 🙂
very interesting subject , great post.
I am rregular visitor, hhow aare yyou everybody?
Thiis piece oof writing posted aat this site iis actually good.
gsvl64
This website can be a stroll-by way of for the entire info you needed about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse right here, and you’ll definitely uncover it.
il2hvy
Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your web site and in accession capital to assert that I acquire in fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Any way I will be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.
ความสนใจ ในการ พนัน “หวยลาว” เป็นหนึ่งในกิจกรรมยอดนิยมในประเทศไทย โดยผู้คนจำนวนมากมักจะ สนใจ ในการเสี่ยง ด้วยความหวังที่จะได้รับ โชคลาภ และ พัฒนา ชีวิตของตนเอง
“หวยลาว” เป็นการ ทำ
ที่ถูกกฎหมายในประเทศลาว และได้รับ ความปรารถนา อย่างมากในหมู่ ผู้คนในไทย โดยเฉพาะอย่างยิ่งในช่วงเทศกาลสำคัญ ๆ เช่น
วันสงกรานต์ วันขึ้นปีใหม่ และช่วงก่อนการออกรางวัลใหญ่ของ”หวยลาว” ผู้คนจะ ต่างพนัน เพื่อลุ้นรับ เงินก้อนโต
ที่จะเปลี่ยนแปลง ชีวิตของพวกเขา
อย่างไรก็ตาม การเล่น
“หวยลาว” ก็ไม่ปราศจากปัญหา เนื่องจากบางคนอาจ
ปรารถนา การพนันและใช้เงินมากเกินไป ส่งผลให้เกิด ปัญหาสังคม นอกจากนี้ การ ซื้อ “หวยลาว” ยังอาจเป็นช่องทางให้คนบางกลุ่ม กระทำการอันไม่ถูกต้อง โดยมิชอบ ด้วยการ ฉ้อโกง
รางวัลของผู้ชนะ
แม้ว่าการ พนัน “หวยลาว” จะเป็นกิจกรรมที่ถูกกฎหมายและได้รับความนิยม ในหมู่ ผู้คนในไทย แต่ควรมีการควบคุม อย่างใกล้ชิดเพื่อป้องกัน ปัญหาที่อาจ ตามหลัง
ทั้งนี้ เพื่อให้การ ซื้อ “หวยลาว” เป็นเพียงการ เล่นเพื่อความสนุก เท่านั้น และ ไม่ทำให้เกิดผลกระทบ ต่อ ความสัมพันธ์ ของ ผู้ที่เกี่ยวข้อง
Here is my web-site :: หวยลาว 3 ตัวตรง ได้ เท่า ไหร่
Wow, this post exceptionally strike the nail upon the mind!
I’ve been battling with this matter for many years and it’s hence
clean in the direction of view somebody incredibly dive deep
into the scenario and supply hassle-free products and services.
The illustrations on your own made available were being astonishingly relatable and I uncovered
myself nodding together as I browse throughout them.
One particular point that particularly resonated with me was the actuality by yourself manufactured regarding the significance of self-treatment.
It’s as a result basic towards attain stuck up inside the working day-toward-working day grind and forget our particular
well being. Nonetheless as by yourself rightly pointed out, using the period in the direction of recharge and prioritize our psychological and actual physical exercise is imperative if we will need toward be our simplest selves.
I’m unquestionably transferring in the direction of check out applying some of the guidelines yourself shared.
Thank yourself for this informative and inspiring article!
I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was great. I don’t know who you are but certainly you’re going to a famous blogger if you are not already 😉 Cheers!
What an perceptive and contemplative post !
I must assert , your examination of this crucial
issue was truly superior .
The breadth and subtlety you brought to the discussion was
exceptional, throwing new understanding on the complexities at play .
I discovered myself affirming as I scanned through your skillfully crafted arguments .
The approach you were empowered to distill the fundamental concepts
excepting streamlining was particularly impressive .
It’s obvious you’ve devoted a significant effort of time into investigating this topic .
This post has given me a great deal to mull over and has
prompted me to reconsider particular components of my personal mindset.
I cherish you taking the resources to share your knowledge – write-ups like this
are immensely precious in advancing the greater discussion .
I look forward to scanning more of your data in the weeks to
come . Please keep up the excellent contributions!
my web-site – microgaming down (microgaming.free.site.pro)
Вещи бренда Balmain доступны для покупки здесь. Погрузитесь в коллекцию модной одежды от знаменитого французского бренда
https://shop.balmain1.ru
Fantastic Comment to Website Critique
Wonderful content! I’m truly enjoying the material in this blog.
Acquire you previously deliberated on procuring encompassed by web-based betting wagering?
Evolution Gaming Site is a amazing site featuring a comprehensive variety of exceptional interactive croupier selections.
The total outing is exceptionally immersive and legitimate, it comes across as
like you’re directly there inside the real gambling venue.
Provided you’re inclined in giving that out, I’d be delighted to thrilled
to provide my special advice connection. The Evolution Gaming Platform offers a great welcome reward for new
first-time bettors. It certainly certainly worthwhile considering further in the event you’re desiring a different online casino activities adventure.
Gratitude further in relation to the fantastic digital diary topic.
Maintain on the brilliant work!
Review my homepage; gambling tax (https://rentry.co/)
This subject matter of this blog piece is really fascinating
. I enjoyed the way you investigated the
numerous issues so extensively and distinctly . You facilitated
me obtain new viewpoints that I never previously deliberated before.
I appreciate for disseminating your knowledge and adeptness
– it has equipped me to improve myself additionally .
I particularly liked the pioneering perspectives you introduced ,
which expanded my horizons and cognition
in meaningful directions . This blog is coherent and
compelling , which is paramount for subject matter of this standard
.
I anticipate to peruse more of your creations in the upcoming period, as I’m certain it shall continue
to be informative and assist me continue growing .
Thanks again !
Feel free to surf to my web site – advantages of playing at international casinos
Salutations, comrade reader. I must laud the author for their
perceptive and well-crafted blog post. The text was both educational and thought-provoking, leaving me with a greater understanding of the area at
hand.
I would desire to extend an recommendation to engage with
the reputable PUSSY888 community. This venue offers a realm of diversion and thrill,
suiting those who revere the finer things in experience.
I urge you to explore the eclectic offerings and
immerse yourself in the exhilarating excursions that await you.
Your participation would be remarkably accepted,
and I await with excitement the chance to discourse with you more
thoroughly within this distinguished electronic realm
Also visit my web blog :: online gambling
Бренд Тиссо — знаменитый швейцарский производитель часовых часов, который славится своим высочайшим качеством и элегантным дизайном. Уже более полутора веков фирма создаёт инновационные хронометры, что завоевали популярность по всему миру.
Новая коллекция часов Tissot
I haven?¦t checked in here for a while as I thought it was getting boring, but the last few posts are good quality so I guess I?¦ll add you back to my everyday bloglist. You deserve it my friend 🙂
Remarkable Article Feedback
Impressive , what a compelling post ! I genuinely relished digesting your analysis on this issue.
As an individual who has been tracking your online presence for
a stretch, I ought to communicate that this is among your greatest skillfully composed and
enthralling writings yet .
The fashion you integrated together viewpoints and
academic data was truly impressive . I found myself as I perused since your points solely felt to
progress so naturally .
Also visit my homepage; bk8 online
I came across your blog post to be a stimulating and astute examination of the
emerging state of the domain . Your evaluation of the
primary changes and obstacles facing establishments in this sector
was outstandingly potent .
As an zealous adherent of this issue , I would
be overjoyed to expand this conversation further .
If you are keen , I would cordially exhort you to discover the captivating possibilities presented at
WM CASINO. Our system supplies a sophisticated and impenetrable context
for collaborating with like-minded adherents and securing a myriad of knowledge to improve
your knowledge of this evolving realm . I look forward to
the prospect of joining forces with you in the foreseeable future
My blog post casinno online
I have recently started a website, the information you offer on this website has helped me tremendously. Thanks for all of your time & work.
Some truly nice and useful information on this internet site, as well I think the design and style has got great features.
Phenomenal Blog Post
Goodness , what an perceptive and meditative piece !
I came across myself affirming as I scanned through your dissection of this pivotal subject .
Your points were well-researched and presented in a clear , captivating manner.
I especially admired how you were equipped to
extract the fundamental nuances and
complexities at operation , without oversimplifying or ignoring the difficulties .
This write-up has offered me a lot to ponder . You’ve undoubtedly
expanded my understanding and modified my perspective
in specific significant forms.
Appreciation for investing the energy to share your proficiency
on this subject . Posts like this are quite a priceless addition to the discourse
. I await with excitement observing what other insightful content
you have in reserve .
My webpage: ebet casino
This material of this blog piece is really fascinating .
I appreciated the way you examined the numerous issues so
thoroughly and unambiguously. You facilitated me obtain innovative viewpoints that I had
not contemplated before. Thank you for sharing your
mastery and competence – it has allowed me to improve myself even more.
I especially relished the ground-breaking standpoints you showcased , which widened my horizons
and cognition in significant trajectories . This blog is well-structured and engaging , which is fundamental
for information of this level .
I wish to review more of your creations in the times ahead , as I’m confident it is sure to continue to be informative and enable me keep growing .
Thanks again !
My homepage casino bonuses
you got a very fantastic website, Gladiola I detected it through yahoo.
The subject matter of this blog post is really fascinating .
I delighted in the way you scrutinized the
diverse issues so exhaustively and clearly .
You assisted me procure new outlooks that I never pondered before.
I appreciate for imparting your proficiency and adeptness – it has enabled me to gain understanding more .
I specifically liked the pioneering perspectives you
presented , which widened my mindset and reasoning in valuable directions .
This blog is coherent and compelling , which is paramount
for information of this level .
I hope to review further of your creations in the
future , as I’m certain it will continue to be informative and assist me persist in developing .
I convey my thankfulness!
my website :: free spins no deposit online casinos
Concluded Reading a Blog Post: A Formal Response
to the Comment Section and an Invitation to Join “KING855”
‘After diligently scrutinizing the blog post, I would like
to offer the following commentary to the section .
Your perspectives on the issue were quite mind-expanding .
I was in alignment with many of the claims you
brought up .
It is heartening to see such an engaging dialogue unfolding.
If you are curious in further delving into this theme,
I would warmly urge you to participate in the “KING855” network .
There , you will have the chance to interact with like-minded participants and delve
deeper into these captivating subjects.
I believe your participation would be a meaningful enhancement to the discussion .
I’m grateful for your remarks, and I look forward to the
prospect of continuing this stimulating conversation.
my web site online casino customer lifetime value
Brought to a close Reading a Blog Post: A Formal Reply
to the Comment Section and an Invitation to Join “KING855”
‘After comprehensively perusing the blog post, I would
like to provide the following contribution to the discussion .
Your opinions concerning the subject matter were quite
fascinating. I was in concurrence with a number of the arguments
you mentioned .
It is heartening to witness such an lively discussion taking place .
If you are inclined in additional examining this subject
matter , I would warmly invite you to become a member of the
“KING855” group . There , you will have the chance to engage
with kindred spirit participants and delve deeper into these
captivating subjects.
I believe your involvement would be a valuable
enhancement to the discourse .
Appreciate your contribution , and I look forward
to the prospect of extending this enriching conversation.
Feel free to surf to my web site; digital casino
thank you for sharing with us, I conceive this website genuinely stands out : D.