I am sure you folks are familiar with the claim that “markets are prone to monopolies.” Let’s just take that as given and accept the conclusion that this requires considerable government interference in the course of voluntary transactions. The data are not very clear that this is, indeed, what happens. Take a look at the persistence of firms in the US, or how long lived the current largest firms really are to get a sense for the monopoly-proneness of the US economy.
But consider this. In every single case where markets have been permitted to be truly voluntary, we have seen unions emerge. And what are unions but labor market monopolists – these are sellers of labor services that ultimately impose higher prices on the buyers of their product and take actions to make it hard for buyers to find substitutes. And indeed, not only does it appear that labor unions emerge always and everywhere we have unfettered capitalism, the largest labor unions tend to persist. Compare the top 20 labor unions today with lists of the top 20 labor unions in 1960 and see how that turnover compares to the concentration of firms on the employer side.
Now this is not an argument against unions or even an indictment of them. In fact, I support the idea of workers voluntarily associating (if that is actually what they do is another question entirely), Rather it is merely intended to have you think about the common arguments levied against firms and ask why they are not applied generally. I just think “firms are them” and “workers are us” and “we just don’t like them” is all this really amounts to. Dress it up in economics if you want, but it is nothing more than homeopathic economics to me.
“Homeopathic economics” — what a useful phrase! It’s one I can use in countless conversations. Thanks for that WC. This will come in handy. There is an economic think-tank where, believie it or not, the phrases “buying local” and “sustainability” are in vogue among the staff.
It ranks right up there with your suggestion to use of the more accurate phrase “government schools” instead of “public schools”.
i suspect its less of a subjective ‘us vs. them’ and more of the mindset that nobody deserves to have extra. their assumption seems to be that suppliers/employers/businesses generally come out on top at the expense of workers, so labor market monopolists are more justified because they help the suppressed and oppressed stay strong. of course those people will have a difficult time telling you whats fair and whats not. and they do not seem to realize that blanket rules to stop all monopolies is likely to hurt employers other than monopolists
533713 496481Wow you hit it on the dot we shall submit to Plurk in addition to Squidoo properly done انواع محركات الطائرات | هندسة نت was great 734151
Muchas gracias. ?Como puedo iniciar sesion?
414389 473599Any way Ill be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post once again soon. I dont believe I could have put it much better myself. 58813
515506 448090Flexibility indicates your space ought to get incremented with the improve in number of weblog users. 395679
333377 377574Most beneficial human beings toasts ought to amuse and present give about the couple. Beginner audio systems previous to obnoxious throngs would be wise to remember often the valuable signal employing grow to be, which is to be an individuals home. best man speech examples 13025
368148 791769 I discovered your weblog web site on google and check a few of your early posts. Continue to maintain up the really very good operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking forward to reading a lot more from you later on! 582945
47717 818771Aw, this was a quite good post. In thought I wish to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and precise effort to make an outstanding article but what can I say I procrastinate alot and under no circumstances appear to get something done. 845631