Feed on
Posts
Comments

I must admit, I have no tolerance for people playing charades. And in no sector do I see such games played more than in education. As I’ve said time and again: education is not about education. Let’s agree to an idea that should cut across party lines and ideological lines. What should we be able to agree upon? That our children grow up to have fulfilling lives, free lives, lives of opportunity and ultimately end up making positive contributions to the world from having been in it. Typically to ensure that this happens we teach our children to read, write, do math and learn and develop other valuable basic skills. We also do this by teaching them (even if informally) cultural values and norms, exposing them to music, art, dance, the outdoors, sports, etc. – in other words, we try to show them the wonders of the world and the wonders of humanity and the wonders of learning about each.

We can also cut across party and ideological lines by temporarily agreeing to disagree on what the proper scale (not scope) of government involvement in ensuring that these things are achieved for our children. Let’s agree that democratic political institutions are responsible to make sure our children achieve some agreed upon level of advancement in these areas. And let’s not debate what this level would be and what is appropriate. Shouldn’t we see a heck of a lot more experimentation and diversity in how we achieve these goals? Is it not utterly startling that virtually every one of the 311 million or so Americans has or will attend government run schools (and if not government run, heavily influenced by them and the graduate programs in education)? Perhaps more astonishing is that most kids go to school with kids the same age, take the same kind of math, reading, science, english, and so on at precisely the same times and in almost the same sequence and in the same settings, and using the same tools. Is it really reasonable to think that all kids learn best this way? Shouldn’t my daughter sometimes be learning with older kids? With younger kids? Does she need to wait until 7th grade to learn biology? Should she start art in Kindergarten? And so on.

The point being is that the way we structure elementary education today is the ultimate form of an input standard. An analogy would be appropriate. Suppose that we are worried that too much coal is being burned by residents of a city which results in unhealthy smog. The goal is to reduce the emissions of harmful particulates into the air. The most extreme version of an “input standard” – or a standard where the authorities decide exactly what is to be done to achieve the goal, would be to ban or mandate reductions in coal use. Why is this undesirable? Because it will possibly achieve the goal of fewer emissions, but it will come at a much higher economic cost than other ways of regulating and also because it drastically reduces the freedom of people to make their own choices – which ought to count for something. Instead of telling everyone to burn 50% less coal, for example, a better regulatory policy would be to set emissions standards for coal users, and penalize users for going beyond such standards. This would be an output standard. The regulators would have control over how much particulate matter is emitted, but it would allow the heterogeneous population to adjust to the standard in ways that are most beneficial to them. Some folks would indeed use less energy. Other folks would take measures to filter their emissions. Perhaps others would switch to other fuels. In any event, the goal would be achieved from the regulatory side, and the costs would be lower while preserving individual sovereignty.

Our current method of education is akin to an input standard. With the goal of having kids become “educated” we simply tell every single one of them how to be educated (and assume it works too). If you were seriously interested in improving the lives of our children and if you were truly serious about doing it cost effectively and respecting the diversity of human capabilities and interests, wouldn’t we see our government take a more “output standard” type of approach to education? Wouldn’t there be myriad ways of getting educational outcomes outside of funding and running government schools as we do? We could simply mandate each family have their children reach a particular standard. We could provide money to other institutions to use freely toward achieving their educational vision. I don’t want to go into particular reform ideas here, just to suggest that hundreds are out there. Any one of those would be preferable to the current situation because it allows for the current system to operate if it was indeed the most preferred – just as under a particulate output standard a choice for individuals would always be to use less coal, just as the input standard recommends.

I can imagine a major objection being that if the desired educational outcomes are not achieved (assuming they are agreed upon and measurable, which are big ifs, a point which I’ll raise in the future – I am not sure we even need to have an objective) then what recourse is there? Suppose a family was given $8,000 per year to ensure their kid met some standard, and when the kid turns 16 those standards are not met, do we want to put families in prison? Do we want to financially penalize them? Not only would the unintended consequences of those policies be awful, the administration of such programs would be prohibitively costly. This objection is hollow however. The current system, particularly for urban minorities, goes beyond failing – it is closer to a national tragedy, and a tragedy that is no closer to being dealt with today than when I was a kid 30 years ago. What are the consequences of failing today? The teachers unions are stronger. The school boards are stronger. The Ed Schools still maintain a tight grip on the accreditation process. The taxpayers don’t get a refund – indeed they end up spending more when poorly educated students end up in poor health, in poor economic circumstances or even in prison. Yikes.

If people really cared about “the children” wouldn’t we see a very aggressive popular movement toward educational experimentation? What is particularly annoying is that edutochracy preaches diversity, creativity, difference and respect for everything except the very product they are responsible for producing. Odd, isn’t it? Either it ain’t about the children, or the edutochracy is too dumb to experiment, or the edutochracy is a hotbed of experimentation and they have concluded that they have it right.

14 Responses to “Zealotry in Education”

  1. Bert says:

    This is an excellent post…and I can’t wait to show it to all my education-major friends and see their reactions.

  2. jb says:

    Devastating. Well done. When I was on the town finance committee I was liason to the school committee. We were spending more on education per capita than almost any other town in the state. When I raised that point the response, in effect, was, yes therefore we are the best. When it comes to public schools success is measured by inputs ($ spent) rather than output (educational attainment).

  3. free chat says:

    714450 197720this is extremely fascinating. thanks for that. we need a lot more web sites like this. i commend you on your fantastic content and excellent topic choices. 225690

  4. 504464 799441My plate is real full and your tryna give me a lot more food, boy what the fuck is wrong wit you?!|guruisthebomb| 448223

  5. x video says:

    177163 431244Really greatest men and women messages are meant to charm allow honor toward groom and bride. Newbie speakers in front of excessive locations should typically our own gold colored dominate in presenting and public speaking, which is to be individual interests home. finest man speach 992171

  6. 957729 528207Hi there! Good post! Please do tell us when I could see a follow up! 444221

  7. medartix.com says:

    Muchos Gracias for your article post. Much obliged.

  8. JorgeCrady says:

    mexico drug stores pharmacies: Mexican Easy Pharm – medication from mexico pharmacy

  9. 426584 876012Can I just now say that of a relief to locate somebody who truly knows what theyre speaking about online. You in fact know how to bring a difficulty to light and function out it crucial. The diet require to see this and appreciate this side on the story. I cant believe youre no a lot more popular since you undoubtedly possess the gift. 805033

  10. source says:

    If you would like to grow your know-how just keep visiting this site
    and be updated with the hottest news posted here.

  11. Hello, Neat post. There’s an issue with your web site in internet explorer, may check this?
    IE nonetheless is the market leader and a big component to folks
    will pass over your great writing due to this problem.

  12. What’s up, its fastidious piece of writing
    on the topic of media print, we all be aware of media is a impressive source
    of data.

  13. El casino 1Win Chile se ha transformado en una
    de las casas de apuestas virtuales más populares en el territorio.
    Su expansión se debe a una serie de características que
    abarcan una variada selección de juegos, ofertas irresistibles y una estructura creada para ofrecer una interacción cómoda y eficiente a los apostadores.
    Gracias a su diseño moderno y simplicidad de navegación, los participantes pueden disfrutar de
    una inmensa oferta de apuestas sin complicaciones.

    Uno de los puntos más fuertes de 1Win Chile es su generoso sistema de bonos.
    Para los usuarios principiantes, la plataforma de juego brinda
    un atractivo beneficio inicial que les da la posibilidad de comenzar con más
    fondos, lo que mejora sustancialmente las oportunidades de ganar.
    Además, los usuarios frecuentes pueden acceder a ofertas especiales, cashbacks y sistemas de beneficios creados para beneficiar a
    los clientes fieles y hacer más entretenida cada jugada.

    El portafolio de entretenimiento es otro de los elementos destacados de este espacio de juegos.

    Los fanáticos de los slots tendrán acceso a una gran diversidad de máquinas,
    desde los de antaño hasta las propuestas innovadoras
    con visualizaciones de última generación y funciones interactivas.
    Para quienes disfrutan más de los títulos clásicos, el casino ofrece diversas
    variantes de ruleta, veintiuno y juego de naipes, brindando variedad para todos los estilos.

    También está activo el casino en vivo, donde
    los aficionados pueden experimentar la emoción de jugar con dealers en vivo en tiempo real.

    Para los entusiastas de las jugadas en deportes, este operador http://1win-bet.cl/ proporciona una extensa gama de opciones en disciplinas como
    el fútbol, el baloncesto, el deporte de raqueta y muchas
    más. Con tarifas de apuesta favorables y una interfaz eficiente
    para predicciones en tiempo real, los jugadores pueden estar atentos
    a sus eventos favoritos y hacer apuestas en tiempo real, elevando la adrenalina
    de cada encuentro. Además, la opción de acceder a la plataforma desde cualquier dispositivo permite a los jugadores
    acceder a sus cuentas y colocar predicciones en cualquier sitio y ocasión.

    La seguridad es una característica esencial para
    1Win Chile. La casa de apuestas implementa tecnologías de encriptación avanzadas para asegurar la información personal y financiera de sus usuarios, garantizando operaciones protegidas y privacidad en todo momento.
    Asimismo, el operador posee una autorización oficial, lo que demuestra su seriedad con la integridad y la legalidad.

    El soporte al cliente es otro de los aspectos clave de
    esta plataforma. Un staff capacitado está preparado para
    aclarar inquietudes y responder preguntas en 24/7.
    Ya sea a través del asistencia en tiempo real, el mensajería digital o la línea
    telefónica, los usuarios pueden ser atendidos de manera rápida y eficiente en caso de cualquier duda.

    1Win Chile se establece como una elección recomendada
    para quienes buscan una interacción confiable y variada.
    Con su amplia selección de entretenimiento, atractivos bonos, apuestas deportivas y un soporte profesional, este operador digital continúa
    ganando popularidad entre los apostadores de Chile.

    La combinación de innovación, seguridad y entretenimiento hace que sea una alternativa recomendada para quienes quieren vivir la experiencia del azar en un lugar de apuestas seguro y atractivo.

  14. 1-win.net.br says:

    O segmento de jogos de azar na internet no Brasil tem aumentado exponencialmente nos últimos anos, e uma das sites de jogos que
    mais se evidencia nesse mercado é a 1Win. Com uma abordagem inovadora e uma navegação simples,
    o site disponibiliza uma jornada imersiva tanto para os fãs das sports betting quanto
    para os fãs de caça-níqueis e jogos de azar.

    A 1Win se firmou 1-win.net.br como uma das sites mais confiáveis para jogos online no Brasil, disponibilizando um ecossistema seguro e
    uma ampla variedade de opções para seus usuários.
    Desde competições esportivas populares, como futebol brasileiro, basquete e tennis,
    até nichos esportivos, há sempre oportunidades para quem deseja colocar palpites e
    testar seus conhecimentos esportivos. Além das
    apostas desportivas, o cassino online da 1Win oferece uma extensa coleção de jogos, incluindo slots,
    roulette, jogo de cartas e Texas Hold’em.

    Esses games são produzidos por alguns dos principais fornecedores, garantindo uma experiência de alta qualidade e gráficos imersivos.

    Os recém-chegados da plataforma podem desfrutar um prêmio inicial extremamente
    generoso, chegando a multiplicando seu primeiro investimento por cinco, o que garante
    uma vivência ainda mais lucrativa ao dar os primeiros passos.
    O inscrição é fácil e descomplicado, podendo ser realizado diretamente pelo plataforma principal da 1Win no Brasil.

    Para quem deseja fazer apostas valendo dinheiro,
    a plataforma oferece diversas formas de depósito, garantindo
    transações financeiras ágeis e confiáveis.
    Além disso, o atendimento está sempre pronto para ajudar para auxiliar os usuários em qualquer pergunta ou situação.

    A experiência proporcionada pela 1Win mescla diversão, proteção e
    chances de lucro. Seja para apostar em eventos esportivos ou para descobrir o mundo do casino online,
    a plataforma se demonstra ser uma alternativa de destaque para quem busca diversão e
    adrenalina no universo do betting digital.

Leave a Reply