Feed on
Posts
Comments

There’s no point in dancing around it. There is little economic justification for taxing the rich. People are envious of others. People seek ways to lower the status of others and raise the status of themselves (I suppose I do that too, I’m no saint). The reason to tax the rich is because”we” don’t like them, and they should be punished.

This is simply nuts. Think about all of the people you don’t like in the world. I don’t like Islanders fans (I’m a Rangers fan – sorry students from Long Island!) I don’t like unmotivated people. I don’t like overeducated people. Heck I sort of hate myself too. Does it follow that all of these folks should be punished and penalized?

But among this same group of rich-envious folks includes a good number of people who believe the government can and should plan many aspects of the economy. So let’s make a deal dear planners. I propose that rather than sticking it to the rich, which can and should impose negative costs on the economy, why doesn’t the state actually act like someone that is trying to add value? Stop laughing!

Seriously, here’s an idea: suppose the reason to tax the rich is to secure more money to build roads and bridges and the like; or suppose that you just want the rich to “pay more” or whatever else you do, why is it so popular to pursue a destructive, property taking approach when there are dozens of other ways to do it?

Isn’t it argued that the rich spend money frivolously? So why not have the wizards in DC and the state capitols offer the rich a deal: we’ll make you some really cool stuff if you agree to buy some of it? Think about this – the government is uniquely positioned to offer goods and services to the rich that I don’t think many private companies would be able to offer without lots and lots of risk.

So check this out: the Russian government will be selling space hotel trips to people in less than 5 years’ time. The cost will be $165,000 for a 5 day stay and $825,000 for the rocket transport. There’s a million dollars of spending right there that is not destructive, since the rich space travelers would have voluntarily paid for it, it adds “aggregate demand” and gets money into the hands of the rocket maintenance people and vendors for example, and does not distort the incentives to work, invest and save. I’d argue that even if these ventures sucked they would be far less harmful than levying taxes.

What is preventing such thinking? After all, the government can do some really intense stuff, and I would argue that even middle class families would drop a pretty sum to experience some of those things. Seriously, how many of you wouldn’t drop lots of dollars to ride in an F-18 hornet?

I know what you’re all going to say:

(1) What if the rich don’t buy the space trips or submarine rides? Aren’t the taxpayers on the hook?

(2) It’s not fair if the rich get to ride on nuclear submarines and blow up icebergs, and the rest of us unwashed masses cannot.

To which I say:

(1) Isn’t that just the same thing as “stimulus” spending?

(2) It’s incredible to live in a world where that is a serious worry.

So what’s the deal envy people? What’s the deal? You get to target the spending of the rich AND you get to play central planner. Don’t you want to do it? And if not, please explain why without contradicting yourself on your tax the rich views.

212 Responses to “A Challenge to Envious Class Warriers”

  1. blink says:

    I like the idea, but I cannot see anyone with a near-religious faith in government picking it up. To many, F-18 rides would be just a step away from renaming the President’s home the McDonald’s White House. After all, priests selling indulgences is a serious black eye.

  2. chuck martel says:

    The McDonald’s White House? Sounds pretty good to me. And instead of naming air craft carriers after dead guys, sell the naming rights to businesses, I like the idea of the USS Viagra steaming off the Virgin Islands.

  3. And where does government get the money to fund the research and development necessary to create space shuttles? Who builds the shuttles when the government demands them to sell to the “rich?” I see little difference between this type of intervention and the traditional method. Either way, it is just men with guns pointing them at innocent people and telling them what to do.

  4. RIT_Rich says:

    Because its hard spending 40+% of GDP by “asking” people to participate. In the end, its not about revenue or spending; its about power. If you believe that you can do better with someone else’s money than they can, you also believe that you shouldn’t have to ask for it.

  5. Rod says:

    I’m almost to the point where I would be willing to have the top 0.035 percent of all earners qualify for a 90 percent tax on all income over $100 million. Not only would that stunt yield next to zero additional revenue and thereby illustrate the truth of the Laffer Curve, but it would also remind people that 0.035 percent of anything, including the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere, is a teeny weenie percentage unlikely to affect anything.

    Let Warren Buffett be the first to face the wrath of Robespierre! [Madame Defarge, who looks suspiciously like Michelle Obama, knits another name into her comforter.

  6. […] A challenge to envious class warriors (note this does not mean all those in favor of taxes do so out of envy, I am directing this at those who seem to have that as a motivation). […]

  7. […] A challenge to envious class warriors (note this does not mean all those in favor of taxes do so out of envy, I am directing this at those who seem to have that as a motivation). […]

  8. 595474 490435I genuinely delighted to uncover this internet website on bing, just what I was looking for : D too saved to fav. 349789

  9. cam tokens says:

    60898 836746I like the valuable info you provide inside your articles. Ill bookmark your blog and check once again here regularly. Im quite certain Ill learn a lot of new stuff right here! Very good luck for the next! 417164

  10. sexy chat says:

    770257 110900There is noticeably a bundle to know about this. I assume you produced certain good points in attributes also 234063

  11. medartix.com says:

    Say, you got a nice blog article.Thanks Again. Really Great.

  12. Thanks so much for the blog post.Thanks Again. Awesome.Loading…

  13. 印傳單 says:

    Kali ubuntu vs sistema operativo cockatoo protection: cuestionario de incursión red de trabajo en una nuez

  14. Immediately I got up and took a shower to wash away the sweat and dry sperm stuck to my penis. After taking a shower, I immediately went downstairs to look for Ms. Yuni.

  15. lexapro (escitalopram) escitalopram dosage chart adults

  16. xnxx porn says:

    Wow! This could be one particular of the most beneficial blogs We have ever arrive across on this subject. Basically Magnificent. I am also an expert in this topic therefore I can understand your effort.

  17. A big thank you for your blog.

  18. Fantastic article post.Thanks Again. Want more.

  19. biyapay says:

    Thanks-a-mundo for the article.Thanks Again. Want more.

  20. I truly appreciate this blog article.Much thanks again. Want more.

  21. wow, awesome blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Cool.

  22. linkin love says:

    Muchos Gracias for your post.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  23. Looking forward to reading more. Great article post. Fantastic.

  24. fillersfairy says:

    I cannot thank you enough for the article post.Thanks Again. Awesome.

  25. accutane india online – accutplus.com accutane coupon pharmacy

  26. blonde porn says:

    checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get several emails with the same

  27. Mua follow says:

    What’s Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It positively helpful and it has helped me outloads. I hope to contribute & aid different users likeits helped me. Great job.

  28. Howdy! This post could not be written any better! Reading this post reminds me of my old room mate! He always kept chatting about this. I will forward this write-up to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read. Many thanks for sharing!

  29. Thank you for another excellent article. The place else may just anyone getthat type of info in such an ideal means of writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week,and I am at the search for such information.

  30. western porn says:

    mixing tadalafil and sildenafil effect of tadalafil on female

  31. water bong says:

    Really enjoyed this article post.Really looking forward to read more.

  32. tuongtaccheo says:

    Hello! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any trouble with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing many months of hard work due to no data backup. Do you have any methods to protect against hackers?

  33. ET says:

    810002 551215Some truly nice stuff on this internet internet site , I like it. 159173

  34. I loved your blog article.Much thanks again. Keep writing.

  35. asian porn says:

    hello!,I really like your writing very a lot! proportion we keep in touch more approximately your article on AOL? I need an expert in this space to solve my problem. May be that is you! Taking a look forward to see you.

  36. crazy porn says:

    Sports betting can also extend to non-athletic events, such as reality show contests and political elections,and non-human contests such as horse racing, greyhound racing,and illegal, underground cockfighting.

  37. 18+ porn says:

    This can be so wonderfully open-handed of you supplying quickly precisely what a volume

  38. What’s up colleagues, nice piece of writing and good urging commented here, I am really enjoying by these.

  39. new porn says:

    Hi there colleagues, how is the whole thing, and what you desire to say regarding this piece of writing,in my view its in fact awesome in favor of me.

  40. Jaunita says:

    canadian online pharmacy ratings legitimate online pharmacies

  41. Looking forward to reading more. Great article post.Much thanks again. Much obliged.Loading…

  42. Jughead says:

    Helo colleagues, its enorrmous article regarding teachingand entirely defined, keep it up alll tthe time.

  43. I value the blog. Awesome.

  44. voucher code says:

    Right now it looks like BlogEngine is the best blogging platform available right now.(from what I’ve read) Is that what you’re using on your blog?

  45. do i have ed canadian pharmacies shipping to usa canadian pharmacy

  46. When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new feedback are added- checkbox and now every time a remark is added I get 4 emails with the same comment. Is there any way you may take away me from that service? Thanks!

  47. GeekBarVape says:

    A big thank you for your article.Thanks Again. Want more.

  48. It’s hard to come by educated people in this particular topic, but you seem like you know what you’re talking about!Thanks

  49. may in 3d says:

    You hold an out ofthe ordinary capability. Your marketing abilities are without a doubt effective. Thanks for writing content over the internet and instructing your readers.

  50. 印傳單 says:

    Stunning quest there. What happened after?Take care!

  51. ice hack says:

    I was able to find good information from yourblog posts.

  52. 314692 500801We are a group of volunteers and opening a new system in our community. Your internet website given us with valuable info to function on. Youve done an impressive job and our entire community will probably be grateful to you. 974092

  53. whoah this blog is excellent i like studying your posts.Keep up the great work! You know, lots of individualsare looking round for this information, you can help them greatly.

  54. Cheers, Excellent information!learn how to write an essay essays writers essay ghostwriter

  55. hello!,I like your writing very much! share we communicate more about your post on AOL? I require an expert on this area to solve my problem. May be that’s you! Looking forward to see you.

  56. I simply wanted to develop a quick comment so as to say thanks to you for the awesome information you are giving on this site. My long internet lookup has now been compensated with extremely good information to write about with my relatives. I would say that most of us site visitors are unequivocally lucky to live in a very good site with many special professionals with useful strategies. I feel somewhat fortunate to have seen the weblog and look forward to so many more fun moments reading here. Thank you once more for all the details.

  57. Logan Kaye says:

    Hi, i think that i saw you visited my website so i came to “return the favor”.I’m attempting to find things to improve my web site!I suppose its ok to use a few of your ideas!!

  58. A person essentially assist to make severely posts I’d state. This is the very first time I frequented your web page and thus far? I surprised with the research you made to make this actual submit amazing. Wonderful task!

  59. Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I’ve truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. After all I’ll be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again very soon!

  60. As a Newbie, I am permanently searching online for articles that can benefit me. Thank you

  61. Hello! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good success. If you know of any please share. Cheers!

  62. Carey Windon says:

    Terrific work! This is the type of info that should be shared around the net. Shame on the search engines for not positioning this post higher! Come on over and visit my website . Thanks =)

  63. Hey, you used to write fantastic, but the last few posts have been kinda boring… I miss your great writings. Past few posts are just a bit out of track! come on!

  64. I’m extremely impressed with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Either way keep up the nice quality writing, it is rare to see a nice blog like this one nowadays..

  65. Heya i’m for the first time here. I came across this board and I in finding It truly useful & it helped me out much. I’m hoping to give one thing back and aid others like you aided me.

  66. I am not sure where you’re getting your information, but great topic. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more. Thanks for great information I was looking for this information for my mission.

  67. Hello.This article was extremely remarkable, especially because I was investigating for thoughts on this subject last Wednesday.

  68. Muchos Gracias for your article.

  69. ivermectin empty stomach ivermectin ingredients

  70. sand crusher says:

    Great, thanks for sharing this blog post.Really thank you! Much obliged.

  71. Aw, this was a really nice post. Findingthe time and actual effort to produce a great article?but what can I say? I hesitate a lot smoking and teens don’t manage to get nearly anything done.

  72. I value the blog article. Really Great.

  73. I really enjoy the blog article.Thanks Again. Really Great.

  74. this website says:

    Hey there! Would you mind if I share your blog with my zynga group? There’s a lot of folks that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Thanks

  75. Thanks so much for the post.Much thanks again. Great.

  76. nsfw ai says:

    Im thankful for the post.Much thanks again. Cool.

  77. dewapoker says:

    Hello.This article was extremely motivating, particularly since I was browsing for thoughts on this topic last week.

  78. your situation; many of us have created some nice practices and we are looking to exchange techniques with others, please shoot me an email if interested.

  79. Really appreciate you sharing this blog post.Thanks Again. Fantastic.

  80. Im grateful for the blog post.Much thanks again. Will read on…

  81. krmoon says:

    Im grateful for the article post.Thanks Again.

  82. Thanks for the article. Will read on…

  83. Thank you for your article post.Much thanks again.

  84. Thanks so much for the article post.Much thanks again. Want more.

  85. I really enjoy the blog post.Much thanks again. Keep writing.

  86. I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoyed every bit of it. I have you bookmarked to look at new things you postÖ

  87. I value the article.Really thank you! Will read on…

  88. This is one awesome article post.Much thanks again. Keep writing.

  89. Great, thanks for sharing this post.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.

  90. 327343 151140The truth is and see if the Hcg diet protocol and as a consequence HCG Drops surely are a in fact quick strategy to be able to shed pounds; while the healthy diet has a strong will most likely moreover sizable focus to undertake positive. hcg diet drops 922373

  91. Many thanks, I appreciate it.easy steps to writing an essay how to write an argumentative essay help writing assignments

  92. Latex hood says:

    wow, awesome post.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

  93. 406000 407183Can anyone assist me out? It is going to be a lot appreciated. 125389

  94. I appreciate you sharing this blog article.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  95. Thanks a lot for the post.Really thank you! Awesome.

  96. 佳文网 says:

    Hey, thanks for the blog article. Keep writing.

  97. more details says:

    Hi there, everything is going fine here and ofcourse every one is sharinginformation, that’s in fact good, keep up writing.

  98. I read this paragraph fully about the resemblance of hottest and previous technologies, it’s awesome article.

  99. Hi, yup this article is truly pleasant and I have learned lot of things from it about blogging. thanks.

  100. sex dolls says:

    Major thankies for the blog.Really thank you! Fantastic.

  101. When I originally commented I clicked the « Notify me when new comments are added » checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get several emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove people from that service? Bless you!

  102. go to see says:

    The best posts, I am very happy to read them, Many people have been helped by this excellent post. Thank you for sharing, I hope you are always healthy

  103. Thanks so much for the blog article. Want more.

  104. arthritis medicine plaquenil chloroquine brand name is plaquenil-induced erythroderma reversible what retinal disorders will not allow you to take plaquenil

  105. Muchos Gracias for your blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Cool.

  106. Greetings! Very useful advice in this particular post! It is the little changes that will make the largest changes. Thanks for sharing!

  107. This post is actually a nice one it assists new net viewers, who are wishing in favor of blogging.

  108. Informative article, totally what I wanted to find.

  109. What’s up, I log on to your blogs regularly. Your story-telling style is awesome, keep doing whatyou’re doing!

  110. Looking forward to reading more. Great article.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

  111. Major thankies for the article post. Really Great.

  112. Wow, great article.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.

  113. ip2 says:

    I really enjoy the blog post.Really thank you! Much obliged.

  114. I cannot thank you enough for the blog. Keep writing.

  115. I really like and appreciate your blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.

  116. Solar Panels says:

    wow, awesome post.Thanks Again. Really Great.

  117. Status AI says:

    I appreciate you sharing this blog post. Will read on…

  118. It’s going to be finish of mine day, but before ending I am reading this enormous post to improve my know-how.

  119. Aw, this was a really nice post. Taking a few minutes and actual effort to create a really good articleÖ but what can I sayÖ I put things off a lot and never manage to get anything done.

  120. Status AI says:

    I cannot thank you enough for the blog post.Thanks Again. Cool.

  121. Thanks designed for sharing such a good opinion, post is pleasant, thats why i have read it entirely

  122. Do you have a spam issue on this blog; I also am a blogger, and I was wondering your situation; we have developed some nice procedures and we are looking to trade solutions with other folks, why not shoot me an email if interested.

  123. Huijue Group says:

    Major thankies for the article post.Thanks Again. Want more.

  124. This paragraph provides clear idea designed for the new people of blogging, thatreally how to do blogging.

  125. Good day! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to getmy blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m notseeing very good results. If you know of any please share.Thanks!

  126. My brother suggested I may like this blog. He was totallyright. This post truly made my day. You can notimagine simply how so much time I had spent for this information! Thank you!

  127. You made various fine points there. I did a search on thetheme and found most people will go along with with your blog.Feel free to surf to my blog Slimingo Keto Reviews

  128. Wuxi Spark says:

    I value the blog.Really thank you! Will read on…

  129. Nuevo ranking actualizado de préstamos rápidos por Internet disponible ahora.

  130. generic chloroquine phosphate hydroxychloroquine plaquenil what is hydroxychloroquine

  131. yum .. I am following you .. Im jasondrealdeal on chattrubate I broadcast also domodeling .. DO you have Dm ? or can dm me ?

  132. fillersfairy says:

    Great, thanks for sharing this post.Thanks Again. Cool.

  133. Prime Biome says:

    I don’t even know the way I ended up right here, but I assumedthis put up used to be good. I do not recognize who you might be butdefinitely you’re going to a famous blogger should you aren’t already.Cheers!

  134. gaming LED says:

    I loved your article.Thanks Again. Great.

  135. Mitolyn says:

    What a stuff of un-ambiguity and preserveness of precious experienceregarding unpredicted emotions.Feel free to surf to my blog post: Radical Slim Keto Reviews

  136. Prodentim says:

    Really nice layout and fantastic content material , practically nothing else we want : D.

  137. gia xe nang says:

    Hey, thanks for the blog.Really looking forward to read more. Great.Loading…

  138. Im obliged for the blog post.Really thank you!

  139. This is a good tip particularly to those fresh to the blogosphere.Short but very precise information

  140. I loved your article.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.

  141. I am continuously searching online for articles that can assist me. Thanks!

  142. Im grateful for the article post. Cool.

  143. disperser says:

    Looking forward to reading more. Great post.Thanks Again. Great.

  144. I need to to thank you for this very good read!! I certainly loved every little bit of it. I have got you bookmarked to look at new stuff you postÖ

  145. ways to treat erectile dysfunction medication for ed dysfunction – ed pills

  146. 佳文网 says:

    Awesome post.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.

  147. Status game says:

    A round of applause for your blog.Thanks Again. Really Great.

  148. Danmajet says:

    Thanks so much for the article post.Really looking forward to read more. Great.

  149. I really like what you guys are usually up too. This type of clever work and coverage! Keep up the terrific works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to our blogroll.

  150. Heya i’m for the first time here. I found this boardand I find It truly useful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to give something backand help others like you aided me.

  151. Great, thanks for sharing this article.Much thanks again. Will read on…

  152. rpsexdoll says:

    Wow, great blog.Really thank you!

  153. What’s up, its nice post regarding media print, weall be familiar with media is a impressive source of data.

  154. I am so grateful for your article post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.

  155. more info says:

    A motivating discussion is definitely worth comment. There’s no doubt that that you ought to write more on this topic, it might not be a taboo matter but usually people don’t talk about these topics. To the next! Cheers!

  156. check says:

    I really like it whenever people get together and share thoughts. Great blog, stick with it!

  157. Wow, great article post.Really looking forward to read more.

  158. to read more says:

    Hi, I log on to your blogs like every week.Your writing style is awesome, keep it up! 0mniartist asmr

  159. Great blog you have here.. It’s hard to find high quality writing like yours these days. I seriously appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!

  160. Heya are using WordPress for your blog platform?I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and create my own.Do you need any html coding expertise to make your own blog?Any help would be greatly appreciated!

  161. Dead composed content material, thanks for entropy. «In the fight between you and the world, back the world.» by Frank Zappa.

  162. Major thanks for the article.Really thank you! Really Great.

  163. scoliosisPretty! This was a really wonderful article. Many thanks for supplying this info.scoliosis

  164. Say, you got a nice article post.Really thank you! Cool.

  165. Really informative article post.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  166. It’s going to be ending of mine day, exceptbefore finish I am reading this enormous post to increase myexperience.

  167. szradiant says:

    Thanks a lot for the article post.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.

  168. I appreciate you sharing this article. Much obliged.

  169. pyproxy says:

    I am so grateful for your article post.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  170. I am no longer certain the place you are getting your information, but good topic.I must spend some time finding out more or figuring out more.Thanks for magnificent info I was in search of this information for my mission.

  171. Wow, great blog.Much thanks again. Cool.

  172. Hey, thanks for the blog article.Much thanks again. Will read on…

  173. Thanks so much for the blog article.Really thank you! Really Great.

  174. Appreciate you sharing, great blog post. Really Cool.

  175. may bo dam says:

    Great blog post.Much thanks again. Fantastic.

  176. Major thanks for the blog article.Thanks Again. Will read on…

  177. hidroxicloroquina hydroxychloroquine vs chloroquine what is hydroxychloroquine

  178. mua server says:

    I as well think therefore, perfectly composed post! .

  179. scoliosisNormally I do not learn article on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up verypressured me to try and do it! Your writing style has been amazed me.Thanks, very great post. scoliosis

  180. I cannot thank you enough for the article post.Thanks Again. Really Cool.

  181. Enjoyed every bit of your blog post.Really thank you! Will read on…

  182. Thanks so much for the article. Fantastic.

  183. stp plant says:

    Enjoyed every bit of your post.Really thank you! Will read on…

  184. Carina says:

    Very neat blog article.Thanks Again. Keep writing.Loading…

  185. 1 says:

    Fantastic blog post.Much thanks again. Really Great.

  186. Say, you got a nice blog.Much thanks again. Want more.

  187. The article is worth reading, I like it very much. I will keep your new articles.

  188. I am so grateful for your blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Great.

  189. I cannot thank you enough for the blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Cool.

  190. Wow, great blog article.Really thank you! Will read on…

  191. Thank you for your article.Thanks Again.

  192. I really like and appreciate your blog article.Much thanks again. Cool.

  193. Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog post. Much obliged.

  194. Very good blog. Will read on…

  195. Hey, thanks for the post.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

  196. game says:

    This text is worth everyone’s attention. Where can I find out more?

  197. Thank you for your post.Thanks Again. Want more.

  198. I think this is a real great article.Thanks Again. Really Great.

  199. Really informative blog article. You’re doing great work. Keep it up.

  200. modalert online modafinil pill – modafinil online

  201. wabo22 says:

    Fantastic blog.Thanks Again. Really Great.

  202. wabo says:

    Im grateful for the blog post.Thanks Again. Really Cool.

  203. f168 says:

    Hello. magnificent job. I did not anticipate this. This is a fantastic story. Thanks!

  204. brokerage says:

    I appreciate you sharing this blog.Really looking forward to read more.

  205. hygge 水療 says:

    Thanks so much for the article post.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

  206. Great info. Lucky me I found your blog by accident (stumbleupon). I’ve book-marked it for later.

  207. Wow, great post. Keep writing.

  208. deepseek says:

    Wow, great article.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.

  209. I cannot thank you enough for the blog.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

  210. to read more says:

    Remarkable things here. I am very satisfied to peer your post.Thanks so much and I am having a look forward to touch you.Will you please drop me a mail?

  211. Im grateful for the blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.

Leave a Reply